Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompt Critique (#2)

(2009 Prompt, Question #1: "Shakespeares Henry VIII, Cardinal Wolsey's Speech")

Critique #1: This student manages to address all parts of the prompt and, in a general sense, produces a well-crafted essay based around a strong thesis. After a brief and intelligent introduction, the student is quick to establish the topic of her essay with a solid thesis statement that emphasizes the complexity of Wolsey's emotional reaction in the passage, a point that was stressed in the rubric. She also provides a number of techniques that Shakespeare used to express said complexity, which is an essential step in thoroughly responding to the prompt. The student's only real issue is a partial lack of effective warrants. For example, his/her usage of Wolsey's flower metaphor, while relevant to the topic of the essay, doesn't directly relate to the claims made in the thesis. The student makes a lot of good points regarding Shakespeare's techniques, but isn't always successful in explaining how those techniques conveyed Wolsey's anger and lamentation. That's not to say the student doesn't provide any acceptable warrants, by any means. Her apt recognition of a tonal shift in Wolsey's speech redeems that portion of the essay, particularly after it's masterfully related to the complexity of Wolsey's response. I'd give this student an 8, maybe even a 9.

Critique #2: This student approaches his topic with a carefully-phrased introduction that effectively outlines her perception of Wolsey's reaction. Though her thesis was less cut and dry than that of the first essay, the student makes up for any minimal lack of clarity in her wording with an impressive fluency. The first body paragraph includes a thoughtful example of how extended metaphor ("the killing frost") is used to communicate Wolsey's emotions, and the student effectively relates it back to the thesis, citing the philosophical sadness of the line in order to support her claim regarding Wolsey's initial despair. Unfortunately, the student runs into trouble in the second body paragraph. Here, the piece basically degenerates into a string of quotes, without enough reasonable explanation for the inclusion of each in between. It seems as though the student fails to come up with sufficient support for the thesis after her first body paragraph, and thusly resorts to listing the various techniques employed by Shakespeare in the passage, regardless of whether or not they support her claims about Wolsey's emotional reaction. For the majority of the essay, the quality of content isn't able to match the student's skillful phrasing. I'd give this student a 5.

Critique #3: This student's essay is rife with continuity issues. Her relatively weak thesis statement, which fails to thoroughly comment on the complexity of Wolsey's response, isn't supported by the rest of her essay. In fact, she concludes it by describing Wolsey's reaction as furious and hysterical, when her thesis makes note of the bitterness and grief present in his response to his dismissal. Also, the student bases her seemingly random claims off of a confused and contradictory interpretation of the better half of Wolsey's speech. For example, she sees Wolsey's lamentation of the human condition to be an indication his eagerness to exact revenge on those who wronged him, a shallow interpretation that overlooks some of the more harrowing themes that Shakespeare probably meant to introduce in this passage. On top of that, the student fails to clearly identify the techniques being explored in each paragraph, making it even more difficult to determine the validity of her claims and warrants. Complete with limited fluency and a number of obvious grammatical and spelling errors, the essay fails to adequately respond to the prompt in a comprehensive way. I'd give this student a 3.


4 comments:

  1. Well done, my good man. You demonstrate excellent writing skills.
    For the first prompt, you mention that the student's "usage of Wolsey's flower metaphor, while relevant to the topic of the essay, doesn't directly relate to the claims made in the thesis." I would argue that it does. The student writes that the "sprouting, blooming, and death of the flower within a three day span . . . reflects Wolsey's anger at how he suddenly fell from favor." Though the student's reasoning is a tad unsupported, I'd say that it does relate to Wolsey's "anger and lamentation," as laid out in the thesis paragraph. Woah, let us not jump to fisticuffs so readily! Our wits may serve as boxing gloves.
    For the second prompt, I think you would have done well to offer suggestions to the student, as if this was a peer-to-peer review. How could the student have supplemented his/her arguments with less quotes?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Eddie, I thought that this was a well-written analysis of the three open prompt essays.
    I liked how you gave some examples of the students’ flaws, such as the first student’s “lack of effective warrants” when I thought it was a perfect essay. Also, although the third student’s essay was relatively awful, I thought that the student would get a 5 because I thought it was just mediocre overall and I was not able to catch some of the details you provided, such as some of the contradictory interpretations in the essay.
    In the critique of the second student, it would have been more helpful if you had discussed how the student could gather more support (helpful especially for me since that is a skill I lack).

    Overall, however, this was a thorough analysis of the three essays.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Eddie.

    Very nice critiques of the 3 essays! However, as you may have already realized, you did a closed prompt instead of an open prompt. So hopefully you choose the right one next time! But you mentioned some very specific examples of what each student did, and they are very good critiques, however, think of critiquing the essay as a whole. I'm not quite sure if this applies to a closed prompt. Write a little more that answers these question "Has the author answered the prompt? Does he/she continue to answer the prompt throughout the essay? How was the word choice? Did they use incorrect terminology? Was there incorrect grammar and or spelling? etc." I actually critiqued an essay where the author wrote 'with' as 'w/'. It's crazy what some students will do. And of course in an open prompt, think about the piece of literature the author choose. Did that fit with the prompt? The critiques you gave were mainly based on the evidence which is very good and that should be the main part of the essay. But just to cover more of the essays, talk about other things a good essay should include too. Overall, very nice job with the critiques though! I'll definitely keep those things in mind for my next essay.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wait my bad Eddie. I forgot to read the last part of your critiques where you did mention a few more of the examples I mentioned earlier. So great job with that! You did include many more varieties of criticism. I will do better next time not to fall asleep and assume I finished reading. So sorry!

      Delete