Sunday, October 27, 2013

Response to Course Material: October

This October has been, by-and-large, a great one--particularly in the AP Lit. classroom. We've occupied the better portion of our time together this month exploring Death of a Salesman, a fascinating and timeless member of the American literary canon, and a play that is quickly becoming one of my personal favorites. Through our absorption and discussion of the text, along with the guidance of Ms. Holmes, we've been able to expand our literary knowledge to include ancient concepts like the definition of Tragedy, as well as the modern author's response to such firmly established institutions. We've also had some opportunities to apply our close-reading techniques, both to Salesman and to a number of poetry selections including "My Father's Song" and "Promises Like Pie Crust". On top of all that, we even managed to squeeze in a little AP multiple choice practice, which has made me feel all the more confident for that ominous date in May.
      As we began to analyze Death of A Salesman following our individual close readings, we were confronted with the difficult question of it's classification. More specifically, was it true tragedy--in the original sense of the word? Ms. Holmes primed the pump with a number of relevant articles including "Tragedy and The Common Man" by Arthur Miller himself. Miller presented the idea that tragedy as genre has evolved to encompass a broader range of human struggle to which modern readers can relate. In contrast to Miller's argument, we know that "Tragedy" is a term refined by centuries of scholarly debate, and while he may have utilized tragic elements in the crafting of his tale, Salesman can't be called a tragedy unless it meets the original criteria. and  After a few days of class discussion, we were still divided regarding the plays status as a tragedy, but I realized how our application of close reading helped us identify different tragic elements present within the text and thusly develop our own conclusions. It was equally enlightening to use the same methods to pull meaning out of the poetry we read as well. The universal nature of close-reading as a tool for analysis really dawned on me this month, especially after uncovering the themes and of motifs of "Promises like Pie Crust".  I particularly enjoyed the poem by Christina Rossetti, mainly because of the satisfaction I gained from recognizing all the little nuances hidden in it's stanzas. As another testament to the value of close-reading, the multiple choice samples we worked on required an in-depth technical examination of a literary passage, similar to what we were doing at home with Salesman. Identifying meaningful uses of diction, syntax, language, etc. helped us determine the themes and motifs that were used to convey meaning from Ulysses's soliloquy in Shakespeare's Troilus and Cressida.
      Reflecting back on our October learning experiences, what sticks with me most is the way in which seemingly insignificant literary techniques can speak volumes about the meaning of a text, and how this necessitates a careful examination following the guidelines of the familiar and omnipresent acronym that is "DIDLS". Let's just say that after this month, I will no longer hesitate to mark up that pristine first page of a new novel, knowing that the key to my understanding of it's content lies in my ability to identify and interpret all the little techniques, right there in the margins.
   











Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompt Critique (#2)

(2009 Prompt, Question #1: "Shakespeares Henry VIII, Cardinal Wolsey's Speech")

Critique #1: This student manages to address all parts of the prompt and, in a general sense, produces a well-crafted essay based around a strong thesis. After a brief and intelligent introduction, the student is quick to establish the topic of her essay with a solid thesis statement that emphasizes the complexity of Wolsey's emotional reaction in the passage, a point that was stressed in the rubric. She also provides a number of techniques that Shakespeare used to express said complexity, which is an essential step in thoroughly responding to the prompt. The student's only real issue is a partial lack of effective warrants. For example, his/her usage of Wolsey's flower metaphor, while relevant to the topic of the essay, doesn't directly relate to the claims made in the thesis. The student makes a lot of good points regarding Shakespeare's techniques, but isn't always successful in explaining how those techniques conveyed Wolsey's anger and lamentation. That's not to say the student doesn't provide any acceptable warrants, by any means. Her apt recognition of a tonal shift in Wolsey's speech redeems that portion of the essay, particularly after it's masterfully related to the complexity of Wolsey's response. I'd give this student an 8, maybe even a 9.

Critique #2: This student approaches his topic with a carefully-phrased introduction that effectively outlines her perception of Wolsey's reaction. Though her thesis was less cut and dry than that of the first essay, the student makes up for any minimal lack of clarity in her wording with an impressive fluency. The first body paragraph includes a thoughtful example of how extended metaphor ("the killing frost") is used to communicate Wolsey's emotions, and the student effectively relates it back to the thesis, citing the philosophical sadness of the line in order to support her claim regarding Wolsey's initial despair. Unfortunately, the student runs into trouble in the second body paragraph. Here, the piece basically degenerates into a string of quotes, without enough reasonable explanation for the inclusion of each in between. It seems as though the student fails to come up with sufficient support for the thesis after her first body paragraph, and thusly resorts to listing the various techniques employed by Shakespeare in the passage, regardless of whether or not they support her claims about Wolsey's emotional reaction. For the majority of the essay, the quality of content isn't able to match the student's skillful phrasing. I'd give this student a 5.

Critique #3: This student's essay is rife with continuity issues. Her relatively weak thesis statement, which fails to thoroughly comment on the complexity of Wolsey's response, isn't supported by the rest of her essay. In fact, she concludes it by describing Wolsey's reaction as furious and hysterical, when her thesis makes note of the bitterness and grief present in his response to his dismissal. Also, the student bases her seemingly random claims off of a confused and contradictory interpretation of the better half of Wolsey's speech. For example, she sees Wolsey's lamentation of the human condition to be an indication his eagerness to exact revenge on those who wronged him, a shallow interpretation that overlooks some of the more harrowing themes that Shakespeare probably meant to introduce in this passage. On top of that, the student fails to clearly identify the techniques being explored in each paragraph, making it even more difficult to determine the validity of her claims and warrants. Complete with limited fluency and a number of obvious grammatical and spelling errors, the essay fails to adequately respond to the prompt in a comprehensive way. I'd give this student a 3.


Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Summary and Analysis: The American Dream

      In Edward Albee, American society found one of it's most thoughtful critics. Born in 1928, the young playwright had his first one-act play published in 1959. His work dealt with broad, gripping themes like societal conformity and family dynamics, and achieved critical acclaim early on. In 1960, Albee completed and published The American Dream, an enigmatic piece that intrigued readers and producers alike. The disturbing cross-section of the modern American condition recognized the gradual deterioration of that which used to define the nation. Albee's fourth play warned readers that the current generation of Americans were gutting the heart and soul of traditional American values and replacing them with a materialistic longing to acquire unattainable satisfaction. The absurdist elements utilized by Albee to represent the social confusion being experienced by the nation eventually helped propel this masterpiece into the the American literary canon.
      The narrative unfolds in a curiously symmetrical--yet otherwise nondescript--apartment in an unidentified city. This "Anytown, USA" setting helps to communicate the universally American nature of the play's message. Right away, we're introduced to the characters of Mommy and Daddy, a married couple with a seemingly unconventional relationship. Mommy requires complete submission of her spouse, so much that she effectively emasculates Daddy--in more ways than one. Mommy provides a prime example of her dominating persona when she says to Daddy, "I have a right to live off of you because I married you, and because I used to let you get on top of me and bump your uglies; and I have a right to all your money when you die."(Albee 67) This line clearly outlines Albee's message regarding traditional American gender roles. He makes it look as though men are in eternal debt to women as soon as they enter into marriage, which emphasizes the emergence of a stronger, domineering role for the female in modern American society. This represents one of the significant departures from traditional American standards around which Albee's play is built. Mommy's quote also exemplifies a new materialistic longing that Albee suggests has become central to the values of modern America. Mommy's emphasis on money and consumerism, not only in the line above ("I have a right to all your money when you die), but throughout the play symbolizes the American peoples' new infatuation with everything that's expensive, fashionable, and fancier than their neighbor's. In fact Mommy's materialistic vision of the ideal family inspired her and Daddy to purchase a child, a "bumble" whom they later mutilate and murder after not being able to gain any satisfaction from their relationship with him. Their actions put the events of the play into motion, and ultimately account for the creation of a new set of American values based around materialism. In addition, Mommy's particular embroilment in the consumer culture, highlighted in her lengthy discussion with Daddy about a trivial hat purchase, indicates Albee's suggestion that modern gender dynamics have inspired the materialistic movement, led largely by women.
      As the narrative progresses, the character of Grandma enters the story, and we're presented with two different yet equally vital relationships that speak volumes about the meaning of the play. Grandma is the mother of Mommy, and is a considerably older character than her and Daddy, and thusly subscribes to a more traditional set of values. She has been essentially cast off by Mommy, and therefore somewhat disregarded by Daddy as well. Because of her inability and refusal to conform to the modern societal standards, she is rendered valueless in the eyes of Mommy, who initially keeps up false pretenses around her mother in order to preserve her image of a normal, happy family. Though Daddy generally complies with Mommy's wishes, he occasionally sticks up for Grandma later on--even if that means just apologizing for his or his wife's behavior--because secretly he can identify with her traditional values more than Mommy's materialistic ideology. When Grandma (in response to an apology from Daddy) says, "Well that's all that counts. People being sorry. Makes you feel better; gives you a sense of dignity, and that's all that's important...a sense of dignity"(Albee 64), we can see that things like dignity and other virtues are more important to her than wealth and physical actractiveness, the sorts of things that Mommy values most highly.
     Albee manifests his central idea that the "American Dream" isn't what it once was in the character of the Young Man. He arrives just as Grandma is about to leave the apartment, sick of the abuse and ignorance she encounters with Mommy. The Young Man is, essentially, the complete opposite of Grandma, who readers have to come to associate with the "American Dream" of a bygone time, as she is of "pioneer stock". His intense physical attractiveness, combined with his lack of any talent or virtue, and topped off with his insatiable hunger for wealth, makes him the ideal foil to Grandma's down-to-earth idealism. When the Young Man says "I have no talents at all, except what you see...my person; my body, my face. In every other way I am incomplete..."(Albee 113) he emphasizes his lack of any real substance. The fact that the Young Man is so fundamentally flawed indicates Albee's belief that the new American longing for a materialistic happiness will not provide legitimate or permanent satisfaction.
     Just as the plot and characters of the play create meaning, so do the literary techniques used by Albee to tell the story. For example, Albee's use of very informal diction and frequent childish slang terms infantilize his characters, drawing a sadly apt comparison between the American people and babies. The names of the characters ("Mommy", "Daddy") reinforce this comparison. Albee also includes a great amount of repitition and cyclical phrasing in this in order to emphasize the lack of original thought or sense of priority in the younger generation of Americans. For example, Mommy and Daddy's constant focus on the lateness of their visitor makes them seem impatient and uninteresting.  The combination of these literary techniques, including the use of symbols like Grandma's boxes (the values of the "Old American Dream") and the emphasis on literal meaning (Daddy's emasculation was evidenced by an actual sex change) inspires many critics to label it as an absurdist-style play. On one level, the meaning associated with the text disqualifies it from that category. In another way, however, the absurdity of the events in the play represent the chaos of social confusion in America during the time the play was published, as a result of a significant shift in societal values.

Sunday, October 13, 2013

Critical Response Essay: These Evangelicals Hate Gays So Much, Life Isn't Worth Living Anymore



http://www.policymic.com/articles/67465/these-evangelicals-hate-gays-so-much-life-isn-t-worth-living-anymore

      As the issue of gay rights continues to permeate our political discussions, groups on the both sides have begun to voice their more radical opinions in hopes of swaying the American majority. In this article, Pierre-Guy Veer focuses on the disturbing ideas of those who condemn homosexuality in the name of religion. He uses rhetorical elements like diction, syntax, and detail to present and criticize the "bigoted" claims of homophobic Evangelicals.
      Throughout the piece, Veer voices his opinions with informal diction. This helps to make the piece feel conversational, and gives it a natural flow that draws in readers. For example, Veer's first line: "Christian conservatives in the U.S. say the darnedest things"(Veer) parodies the common expression, "kids say the darnedest things", a humorous bit of wordplay that provides readers with a simple, familiar phrase while communicating his disapproval of religious extremism. While his use of diction helps to draw readers in, it also establishes a passionate tone for the piece that indicates how strongly Veer feels about the topic. He refers to the Christian conservative rhetoric as "old, bigoted, intolerant nonsense"(Veer). Harsh language such as that makes the piece feel almost like an invective, and in this way, Veer clearly distinguishes his op-ed piece from other fact-based articles.
      In addition to diction, syntactical choices made by Veer had a significant effect on the expression of his opinion. His relentless criticism of Christian conservatives is highlighted by the driving and repetitive arrangement of his phrasing. For example, Veer starts a number of his sentences with the words "if they", "they" or "their", referring to the Evangelicals. He often finishes the sentence with an example of their bigotry, or a mocking suggestion like the following: "If they are so unhappy in Western countries, then surely they can go elsewhere"(Veer). This form of sentence construction gives the piece an accusatory feel that very clearly communicates Veer's opinion. He also employs parallel syntax to perform a similar role in the text. Veer says, "There is no homosexual lifestyle...and there is no gay agenda"(Veer). The two sentences are paired together by their near identical beginnings, the declaratory nature of which helps to hammer Veer's point home and convince readers of his passion for the topic and his confidence in his critique of Evangelical homophobia.
      Detail also plays a significant role in strengthening Veer's criticism. He uses specific examples of claims made by radical Christian conservatives to expose their absurd ideology to his readers and thusly justify his criticism. For example, he cited a Winston Churchill quote about The Second World War used by a prominent Evangelical activist group to emphasize their disturbing application of it to their own fight against equal rights. The inclusion of such detail provides support for his admonishment of conservative social ideology.  Veer also suggests that "they could go to the Arabian Peninsula, where homosexuality is punishable by death. However, non-muslims, when not persecuted, are totally unfree, especially in cases of apostasy"(Veer). This information regarding backwards global conditions strengthens his argument by highlighting the hypocrisy of Evangelicals, proving that in a place where one group is so harshly persecuted, no one truly enjoys the benefits of freedom. This level of detail throughout the piece helps to expose the intolerance of radical Evangelicals and justify Veer's criticism of them.
      Veer's piece functions not only as a much-needed attack on the enemies of human rights, but also as a prime example of how literary techniques can help communicate the message of a piece. Thanks to his use of diction, syntax and detail, Veer was able to effectively present the claims and ideology of radical Christian conservatives, and subsequently invalidate them with a nice dose of reality.