Sunday, October 13, 2013
Critical Response Essay: These Evangelicals Hate Gays So Much, Life Isn't Worth Living Anymore
http://www.policymic.com/articles/67465/these-evangelicals-hate-gays-so-much-life-isn-t-worth-living-anymore
As the issue of gay rights continues to permeate our political discussions, groups on the both sides have begun to voice their more radical opinions in hopes of swaying the American majority. In this article, Pierre-Guy Veer focuses on the disturbing ideas of those who condemn homosexuality in the name of religion. He uses rhetorical elements like diction, syntax, and detail to present and criticize the "bigoted" claims of homophobic Evangelicals.
Throughout the piece, Veer voices his opinions with informal diction. This helps to make the piece feel conversational, and gives it a natural flow that draws in readers. For example, Veer's first line: "Christian conservatives in the U.S. say the darnedest things"(Veer) parodies the common expression, "kids say the darnedest things", a humorous bit of wordplay that provides readers with a simple, familiar phrase while communicating his disapproval of religious extremism. While his use of diction helps to draw readers in, it also establishes a passionate tone for the piece that indicates how strongly Veer feels about the topic. He refers to the Christian conservative rhetoric as "old, bigoted, intolerant nonsense"(Veer). Harsh language such as that makes the piece feel almost like an invective, and in this way, Veer clearly distinguishes his op-ed piece from other fact-based articles.
In addition to diction, syntactical choices made by Veer had a significant effect on the expression of his opinion. His relentless criticism of Christian conservatives is highlighted by the driving and repetitive arrangement of his phrasing. For example, Veer starts a number of his sentences with the words "if they", "they" or "their", referring to the Evangelicals. He often finishes the sentence with an example of their bigotry, or a mocking suggestion like the following: "If they are so unhappy in Western countries, then surely they can go elsewhere"(Veer). This form of sentence construction gives the piece an accusatory feel that very clearly communicates Veer's opinion. He also employs parallel syntax to perform a similar role in the text. Veer says, "There is no homosexual lifestyle...and there is no gay agenda"(Veer). The two sentences are paired together by their near identical beginnings, the declaratory nature of which helps to hammer Veer's point home and convince readers of his passion for the topic and his confidence in his critique of Evangelical homophobia.
Detail also plays a significant role in strengthening Veer's criticism. He uses specific examples of claims made by radical Christian conservatives to expose their absurd ideology to his readers and thusly justify his criticism. For example, he cited a Winston Churchill quote about The Second World War used by a prominent Evangelical activist group to emphasize their disturbing application of it to their own fight against equal rights. The inclusion of such detail provides support for his admonishment of conservative social ideology. Veer also suggests that "they could go to the Arabian Peninsula, where homosexuality is punishable by death. However, non-muslims, when not persecuted, are totally unfree, especially in cases of apostasy"(Veer). This information regarding backwards global conditions strengthens his argument by highlighting the hypocrisy of Evangelicals, proving that in a place where one group is so harshly persecuted, no one truly enjoys the benefits of freedom. This level of detail throughout the piece helps to expose the intolerance of radical Evangelicals and justify Veer's criticism of them.
Veer's piece functions not only as a much-needed attack on the enemies of human rights, but also as a prime example of how literary techniques can help communicate the message of a piece. Thanks to his use of diction, syntax and detail, Veer was able to effectively present the claims and ideology of radical Christian conservatives, and subsequently invalidate them with a nice dose of reality.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Eddie, this was overall a well-written analysis.
ReplyDeleteWhenever I read about the logic of homophobes, I tend to chuckle. As Ms. Holmes had once said in 1st hour, “The average IQ is 100: so for someone above it, there’s someone below it. “ (something like that).
I agree that the author’s informal diction made the reading not only more understandable, but also more enjoyable. The wordplay with the phrase “kids say the darnedest things” where the author compares evangelical anti-gays to little children was interesting to read about, and I liked how you were able to pick-up on that and explain it well.
Also, I too noticed that the author seems to have an accusatory syntax throughout his article, which you explained well in your second body paragraph. I thought this was a great way for him to belittle the anti-gay’s logic.
This article was partially a satire, especially in the somewhat sardonic fifth paragraph. And the way he made it a satire is through details, which you explained well in your third body paragraph.
Again, I thought that this was a well-written, thorough analysis of a relatively shorter article.
First off, you picked the perfect article for this assignment: strongly voiced, and very short. You're going places.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I think you may have made this assignment unintentionally difficult for yourself by picking an article of such intense shortness. I think a longer article would ease the burden of finding good examples of literary techniques.
That's not to say that you didn't have enough examples. In fact, I would wager the opposite. Your arguments are very well supported with quotes.
In your post's end, you write that "Veer was able to effectively present the claims and ideology of radical Christian conservatives." I don't think that's true. I think what Veer presented was a very narrow, specific portion of conservative Christianity, the portion that happens to be hateful and bigoted. I'd be more cautious of making such broad statements about portions of the population.
But I'm nit-picking. It's still a great post.
Ok Eddie, this is my last post so don't mind me if I display a little too much enthusiasm.
ReplyDeleteTo start off, that title really caught my eye, and I actually laughed out loud when I read it. It obviously is very opinionated. Great choice! (not to mention it's length). I liked the many examples you had and your support for each. The diction choices were good, and you explained them clearly. I especially liked your last example for syntax with the comparison. Very smart. I really don't have much to critique in your article. However, I would suggest using a longer article in the future. There are more examples and more solid arguments can be made from an article that has more substance. That's not to say you're essay wan't great. It is great! I just felt that the article was too short to have any valuable arguments. All of your examples were supported with evidence and you made a thorough argument. Very nice job!
Eddie--Well done! You've addressed the concerns of your Sept peer reviewers about adequate evidence, here, and written quite an effective and insightful argument, besides!
ReplyDelete