Sunday, March 16, 2014

Response to Course Material: March

      Ah, March: the threshold of spring. How terribly ironic for us Michiganders. In AP Lit., this chilly month has been stuffed with a variety of fascinating literary lessons, related in ways that--to be honest--I'm still figuring out. Following our wrap-up of RGAD, we took a brief hiatus from our constant dramatic analysis to explore a range of different literary works and multi-media presentations, beginning with some enlightening cultural essays written by Leslie Marmon Silko, the author of Ceremony. The essays contained valuable information regarding--among other things--the importance of the oral tradition to the Laguna Pueblo people, and went into considerable detail to depict some of the most culturally significant stories passed down through their generations. Reading Silko's work reminded me of some of the material we read in American Literature on American Indian tribes and the mythology around which their culture is based. Silko's description of a story in which a ka'tsina spirit known as "The Gambler" stole the rain-giving clouds as an ante for a bet particularly resonated with me, as I recognized the mischievous trickster spirit as a possible common archetype associated with tribal mythology. The character reminded me in particular of Loki--the infamous trickster god of Norse origins who happened to be prominently featured in the recently released Avengers movie. That connection got me thinking about shared symbols, which segued beautifully into the critical lenses powerpoint we viewed later in the week.
       The powerpoint and our subsequent in-class discussion was useful in refreshing my memory regarding the various methods by which to analyze literature, as well as introduce me to a few I had never really been familiar with (Literary Darwinism, anybody?). I felt most comfortable with Marxism and Historical Criticism, two tried-and-true lenses that Ms. Huntley had us using quite frequently last year in Brit. Lit. As a class, however, we struggled right away as we tried to analyze The American Dream from a Feminist viewpoint. It seemed as though our understanding of that particular critical method was pretty vague, and it took extensive guidance from Ms. Holmes before we were able to get anywhere. I had used a Feminist lens numerous times in my analysis of Jane Eyre last year, and it seems I didn't quite have the hold on it that I thought I did. Oh well, you live and you learn. Time to go burn all those critical analysis papers on Brönte.
      Anyway, I found the lesson on Northrop Frye's "Mythoi" to be hands-down the most intriguing of the month. His categorized, methodical approach to literature especially appealed to me as someone who likes to stay organized. It was also quite satisfying to recall Foster's How to Read Literature Like a Professor And recognize a lot of Frye's ideas in those chapters. Aside from that though, I found myself disagreeing with a number of my classmates when classifying works we've read under one of Frye's four seasonally-themed labels. It seems as though his system doesn't always account for the various nuances in works of modern literature like The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, for example. My understanding of his work is by no means complete, though, and I'd like to spend more time with it in the near future.
      Regarding the next piece on our analytic docket, I've found Ceremony to be a powerful, gut-wrenching read. It's required a complete investment of focus due to the frequent chronological jumps, but so far it has been very rewarding. I can't wait to hear everyone's ideas and opinions. I unfortunately missed our first day of discussion on Monday due to a nasty illness. However, I heard we didn't cover too much in sixth hour, save constructing a family tree in order to get the characters straight, so I'm not very worried about catching up. That about covers our work in AP Lit. these past couple of weeks--here's to further literary enlightenment and better weather!

Sunday, March 9, 2014

Open Prompt Response #2

(2004 Prompt, Question #3: Critic Roland Barthes has said, "Literature is the question minus the answer." Choose a novel, or play, and, considering Barthes' observation, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the author's treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary.)

In Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead, Tom Stoppard re-introduces readers to a pair of bumbling minor characters from Shakespeare's Hamlet, as they wander without purpose or direction through someone else's play. Through their own constant inaction, as well as a number of mysterious clues provided by a curious troupe of tragedians, Stoppard establishes that within their literary realm, the ultimate fate of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern is contained in the very script by which they operate. In this way, Stoppard asserts that characters--existing only in a work of art--are completely without free will or a sense of control. However, by making careful distinctions between his characters and the audience watching them (and consequently art and reality) throughout the play, Stoppard both raises answers the question: "Do we, real humans, have a sense of control, or is it merely an illusion that we endorse?"
      From the moment the titular duo arrives on stage, it is already clear that they are defined by their idleness. We first find them betting on the flip of a coin--for nearly the 100th time. Arbitrary games like these occupy their time whenever they aren't fulfilling their obligations as characters in Hamlet, suggesting that any sense of purpose they had during their "scenes" vanishes once they are on their own outside of the action. Another character, the enigmatic Player, also gives us reason to believe that the pair's fate is beyond their control. In fact, he even goes so far as to respond to one of Rosencrantz's mindless queries with: "Decides? It is written." Another equally conspicuous example of the Player's peculiar sense of awareness is his troupe's foretelling performance that depicts Ros and Guil's deaths right in front of their own puzzled faces. Ros and Guil's inability to put two and two together says something about their characters in and of itself. After all, they couldn't possibly exercise free will if they aren't even aware of their situation.
      While concurrently establishing the doomed nature of the play's protagonists, Stoppard also emphasizes a distinct separation between the characters onstage and the audience off. Often times, Ros and Guil themselves acknowledge the different features of the stage on which they are confined, paying particular attention to the footlights, as if they represent some sort of final barrier that keeps them from escaping the horrifying, cyclical eternity they are forced to endure as characters. In the third act, the two express particular longing to escape from their play. In fact, Ros even considers "jumping ship" and joining the audience in reality at one point, only to be discouraged by Guil's brief yet tragic intuition that "they" (the authors) are probably expecting it.
      Ultimately the sad plight of the titular characters, and the obvious evidence that they are confined to the literary work in which their fate is written begs us readers to reflect inwards to some degree. Stoppard asks us: Do you have control? Can you exercise free will? And, in much the same way that he asked that question, he answers it. Though he meant for his characters to reflect certain aspects of human nature which he undoubtedly finds somewhat weak or pathetic--such as indecision or indifference--he clearly intended for us to recognize that his characters are trapped within their play, while we exist in an entirely different realm that is as chaotic and complex as theirs, but remains magnificently unscripted. By way of this difference, he breaks off the possibility of relation to these characters, and reminds us that we do possess free will, and that we should employ it in a way that allows us to find purpose and a sense of identity, two things that his bewildered protagonists severely lack, and can never obtain.


Thursday, March 6, 2014

Summary and Analysis: Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead

Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead


Author:
English playwright Sir Tom Stoppard (knighted in 1997) wrote Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead in 1964. His breadth of work is generally associated with the postmodernist movement and includes but is not limited to Arcadia, Cost of Utopia, and Every Good Boy Deserves Favours.

Setting:
A locale "without any visible character", the castle Elsinore, a stage...

Characters:
Rosencrantz (Henceforward know as Ros)-
A dim-witted Elizabethan who, like his friend Guildenstern, struggles to comprehend the world around him or come to grips with his own identity. Unlike his traveling partner, however, he remains blissfully ignorant throughout most of the play, content in his complete unawareness of his surroundings and limited control of his place within them. Only towards the end of the play does this lack of control cause him any real strife.

Guildenstern (Henceforward known as Guil)-
A pretentious Elizabethan who, like his friend Ros, struggles to comprehend the world around him or come to grips with his own identity. Unlike his travelling partner, however, he puzzles endlessly throughout the narrative, constantly utilizing mechanisms of logic and rationale to understand their situation within their surroundings and establish a sense of control, but to no avail. Despite his mental effort, Guildenstern fails to reach the sort of enlightenment or empowerment that he seeks.

The Player-
The mysterious leader of a troupe of Elizabethan actors/male prostitutes that encounter Ros and Guil on their travels. Unlike the two hapless travelers, the player and his merry band seem to exist on a different plane of reality, merely visiting the realm in which Ros & Guil are trapped. The Player frequently hints at his understanding of their existence with a play with a scripted sequence of events. In addition, his philosophies on creating and consuming art, which he reveals to Ros & Guil, hint eerily at this. In his own right, he also seems to play an important role in the direction of the two titular characters through his troupe's performance as they meet them in the forest as well as within the action of Hamlet, when they foretell the events of the play through a dumbshow.

Hamlet Characters-
Hamlet, Horatio, Claudius, Gertrude, Ophelia, Polonius, etc.

Plot Summary:
Act I
The play begins with Ros and Guild traveling through a trait-less landscape flipping a coin that has landed heads 90 consecutive times. This phenomenon perturbs Guil, who struggles to reconcile the state of events with his own preconceived notions regarding logic and linguistics. Ros isn't concerned by the peculiar outcome of their game, save a little guilt for winning so many times. The two reflect on their journey thus far and are only able to recall a summons they received from an unknown messenger, and the notion that it was to perform some important duty. The pair encounters a troupe of actors led by a charismatic artist known as The Player. The Player encourages them to stay and be entertained by a performance, but it soon becomes clear that the actors are also willing to provide Ros and Guil with sexual favors if it equates to a few coins lining their pockets. Ros's initial interest morphs into shame and disgust and while Guil turns to violence in the face of his confusion. Feeling threatened, the Player turns to leave, but not before Guil invites him to bet on a coin toss. The Player loses repeatedly, and then walks away. Suddenly, we're transported to Elsinore as Ros and Guild appear in a scene from Hamlet. King Claudius and his queen Gertrude enlist the duo with task of discovering what ails Hamlet and finding a way to cheer him up. After the leave, Ros and Guild find themselves wandering through the vast castle void of purpose, occupying passing the time with a game in which the goal is to communicate entirely through questions. When they see Hamlet pass by, they decide to practice for their impending interaction with him by acting as him. Through a series of questions, some utterly insipid, the two eventually determine that Hamlet's torment stems from the fact that Gertrude (his mother) was so quick to marry Claudius (his uncle) after his father's death. Hamlet then reenters and welcomes Ros and Guil to Elsinore, marking the end of Act I.

Act II
Act II begins in the middle of a conversation between Hamlet and the titular characters, in which he assures his childhood friends that his madness is, to some degree, merely an act. Once he leaves Ros and Guil despair over how little they have actually gleaned from Hamlet. Soon enough, The Player shows up and insists that Ros and Guil question their situation too much, and informs them that Hamlet has resquested of his troop a play titled The Murder of Gonzago, into which he inserted a number of lines to be memorized by The Player. He also tells them that he thinks Hamlet's madness might have to do with his adoration of Ophelia. After The Player leaves, Ros and Guil ponder death, much to the chagrin of Guil. Later the pair watches the tragedians rehearse for their performance for King Claudius and his royal court. In a dumbshow, the actors depict the general situation involving Old Hamlet, Claudius, and Gertrude. Hamlet and Ophelia burst through the rehearsal, each in somewhat of a hysterical fit. After Hamlet runs off (Get thee to a nunnery!), Claudius and Polonius enter, and Claudius determines the best course of action is to send Hamlet to England where he cannot cause any more turmoil within Denmark. They leave, and the dress rehearsal resumes, but Guil isn't satisfied. He finds the tragedian's performance to be uninteresting, as it doesn't reflect reality. The rehearsal continues and the player's foretell the rest of the action of Hamlet including the deaths of Ros and Guil, but they don't realize it. Instead, Guil gets upset again, claiming that actors cannot effectively portray death. Later, Hamlet kills Polonious, as predicted by the tragedians. Ros and Guil are instructed to find Hamlet and, consequently, Polonius's body. After they fail to do so, they are tasked with accompanying Hamlet to England.

Act III
The act begins with Ros and Guil awakening in darkness, and after some nonsensical guessing regarding their situation, realizing that they are on a boat bound for England. Ros panics somewhat, expressing his disbelief in England as a concept. In response, the two play a role-playing game (similar to the one they played at Elsinore) in which they take turns impersonating the King of England. Shortly thereafter, they open the letter given to them by Claudius and find that Hamlet is sentenced to death upon his arrival in England. They decide to let it happen, as it is ultimately none of their business. The next morning, the duo awaken to find the tragedians stowed away on the ship, following a hasty escape from Elsinore. Their ship is attacked by a band of pirates, and the whole gang (including Hamlet) hides in barrels on the ship's deck. In the confusion of the raid, Hamlet disappears. Once Ros and Guil discover this, they begin to panic again, repeating their role-playing game from earlier. This leads to them re-reading the letter, only to find it has been altered to order their own deaths. Following this, Guil lashes out at the actors for trying to act out death. In an attempt to demonstrate his meaning somehow, he purloins The Players own dagger and stabs him with it. The Player supposedly dies, convincing everyone onboard the ship, but then reveals that the dagger was a toy and that he is unharmed, ridiculing Guil. The Player and his troupe disappear after putting on a final, gruesome performance.  The titular pair are left alone on the ship. Ros is dismayed initially, as he feels they are entitled for some sort of reason for their deaths. He then changes his tune, deciding he is more relieved than anything else, and disappearing without a trace. Guil ponders their situation for a while longer, but ultimately disappears as well. The play ends with the final scene of Hamlet, in which Horatio delivers his final speech following the culminating bloodbath.

Narrative Voice:
As it is a play, there is no specific narrator. 

Author's Style:
Point-of-View- 
Stoppard takes a rather cynical point of view on human nature through RGAD. He uses his characters to reflect the weakness and indecision that characterize the human race as a whole, and laments our inability to recognize our own sense of control by emphasizing his character's complete lack of any.

Tone-
The tone of the play is an interesting fusion of lightheartedness, mystery, and discomfort. Stoppard presents his readers with an eerily ambiguous narrative in a very playful way, utilizing humorous literary techniques like wordplay that contrast an unsettling underlying message.

Imagery-
Stoppard, as a playwright, doesn't make heavy use of imagery as his work is performed in front of the audience.

Symbolism-
The boat by which Ros and Guil travel to England serves as a symbol for life and the human experience, representing how though we are given some mobility and free will in life, we are all ultimately headed towards the final destination, which in this case is symbolized by the nebulous isle of England. Additionally, the coins--and their baffling statistical outcomes after being flipped--symbolize the superfluity of reason and logic in a universe where the laws of reality are governed and can be altered by an omnipotent entity.

Quotes:

"Words, words. They're all we have to go on."(pg. 41)
This quote enforces a prominent motif within the work that is the unreliability of language. Ros and Guil operate completely based off of linguistic commands that ultimately cause them to become more bewildered and directionless. Through this, Stoppard comments on how the fallability of our most common method of communication mystifies our surroundings and identities, preventing action or further self-discovery.

"What a fine persecution...to be intrigued without ever quite being enlightened."(pg. 41)
This quote essentially sums up the character of Guildenstern..he is the epitome of ignorance, yet he searches desperately for some sort of perspective, coming very close at certain points in the play, but ultimately falling back on that crutch of human nature that prevents him from every fully realizing his situation within his universe, or at least not enough to assume any kind of control.

"Well, we'll know better next time."(pg. 126)
This quote greatly contributes to the unsettling tone near the end of the play. Guildenstern seems so utterly alone here as he confirms the notion that they are in fact merely characters, existing outside of reality, doomed to relive the mundane events of their minor roles each time someone opens up Hamlet. In this way, Stoppard capitalizes on his motif equating theatre-going to prostitution or voyeurism. It's as if Stoppard wants us to fell like we're forcing these characters to struggle through a complex and unyielding universe in which they are utterly lost for the sake of our own enjoyment. In this humorously sick way, Stoppard insists that the consumption of true art is not to be taken lightly.

Theme:
In Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead, Stoppard comments on the tendencies of human nature to forego control and adhere to a higher social or moral construct that obscures self-awareness and inhibits self-discovery, and suggests that as we do not share the sad plight of his titular characters, it is our responsibility responsible to take full advantage of our free will in order achieve a greater level of understanding in the face of a complex and chaotic world.
Stoppard uses the characters of Ros and Guil to reflect on regular people who, outside of their mass of external responsibilities that guide their lives, which in Ros and Guil's case, is their limited involvement in the plot of Hamlet, fail to come to any real understanding of the world around them or establish a strong identity. Instead, they are just drifting, and Stoppard uses the symbol of a boat to capture this metaphor. However, Stoppard emphasizes a separation between reality and art that makes his characters fundamentally different from his readers. After all, Ros and Guil's lives are dictated by the script of the play in which they exist, as we noted by the tragedians foreboding dress rehearsal in Act II. The title emphasizes this as well, slyly commenting on the fact that the clueless pair are, for all purposes, dead before the action of either play even begins. Through this important differntiation, Stoppard urges us--his readers--to behave accordingly, and act in earnest to gain a greater understanding of our surroundings, while concurrently developing a strong identity rooted in the understanding that we have control over our lives.