As we began to analyze Death of A Salesman following our individual close readings, we were confronted with the difficult question of it's classification. More specifically, was it true tragedy--in the original sense of the word? Ms. Holmes primed the pump with a number of relevant articles including "Tragedy and The Common Man" by Arthur Miller himself. Miller presented the idea that tragedy as genre has evolved to encompass a broader range of human struggle to which modern readers can relate. In contrast to Miller's argument, we know that "Tragedy" is a term refined by centuries of scholarly debate, and while he may have utilized tragic elements in the crafting of his tale, Salesman can't be called a tragedy unless it meets the original criteria. and After a few days of class discussion, we were still divided regarding the plays status as a tragedy, but I realized how our application of close reading helped us identify different tragic elements present within the text and thusly develop our own conclusions. It was equally enlightening to use the same methods to pull meaning out of the poetry we read as well. The universal nature of close-reading as a tool for analysis really dawned on me this month, especially after uncovering the themes and of motifs of "Promises like Pie Crust". I particularly enjoyed the poem by Christina Rossetti, mainly because of the satisfaction I gained from recognizing all the little nuances hidden in it's stanzas. As another testament to the value of close-reading, the multiple choice samples we worked on required an in-depth technical examination of a literary passage, similar to what we were doing at home with Salesman. Identifying meaningful uses of diction, syntax, language, etc. helped us determine the themes and motifs that were used to convey meaning from Ulysses's soliloquy in Shakespeare's Troilus and Cressida.
Reflecting back on our October learning experiences, what sticks with me most is the way in which seemingly insignificant literary techniques can speak volumes about the meaning of a text, and how this necessitates a careful examination following the guidelines of the familiar and omnipresent acronym that is "DIDLS". Let's just say that after this month, I will no longer hesitate to mark up that pristine first page of a new novel, knowing that the key to my understanding of it's content lies in my ability to identify and interpret all the little techniques, right there in the margins.
I'm glad that you're seeing so much value in annotations! Great job covering the material and reflecting on its significance to you--I would like to see a bit more synthesis of material across the course and connecting of the material to experiences (academic and otherwise) from outside of this course.
ReplyDeleteTo quote our good friend Borat, this post is "very nice." You cover our classroom material well, and provide good descriptions of your reactions to said material. My favorite part of this post is the portion where you connect our close reading of Death of a Salesman to "Promises like Pie Crust" and Troilus and Cressida. However, much like our nation's economy, there's room for some growth. You should elaborate more on connections between the classroom materials, and outside sources. How could you connect our discussion of "tragedy" to The American Dream? How does it relate to a tragic film you've seen recently? You also fall a little bit into the trap of just reciting what we did in class, so I'd exercise more caution next time.
ReplyDeleteHi Eddie.
ReplyDeleteNice job on this post! You included a lot of details that I failed to mention in my own blog and a few connections, however, like in your comment to my blog post, you could have added those ideas into this blog post about the connections between "American Dream" and "Death of a Salesman". Like Simon mentioned above, I did notice a little bit of 'reciting' so I would recommend starting to connect class ideas to your own life, OUTSIDE the classroom such as personal values changing or a different view on people after reading certain pieces. However, on the brighter side, even if we weren't in the same class, I would definitely be able see your enthusiasm for the class and your value of the material we've learned. Your voice stood out and it was enjoyable to read overall. Just mention a bit more for those of us who went through the same motions and lectures/discussions.
Eddie, this was a well-written response to our course materials.
ReplyDeleteThis response only lacked connections to your experience in reading other compositions, such as “The American Dream” since they are both plays that discuss relatively the same theme. This also seems like recitation, although it was proficiently interspersed with comments regarding your reactions. I can see that not only are you enthusiastic about AP Literature, but also you are changing your mentality when comes to literary analysis due to this course. I too one had thought many components of DIDLS were pointless (syntax especially) until we employed that analysis technique on poems like “Promises like Pie-Crust” and “Death of a Salesman”.
Unlike you, I personally preferred “The American Dream” to “Death of a Salesman” because I liked the humor and absurdness of the piece. I do not understand why Arthur Miller found his play to be “funny”, I thought it was overall a sad piece; perhaps even a tragedy if you agree with Miller’s thesis in “Tragedy and the Common Man”.
Again, this response was thorough and enjoyable to read. Just remember to make connections.