Sunday, December 15, 2013

Open Prompt Critique (#4)

(2008 Prompt, Question #3: "Function of a Foil")

Critique #1: This student answers both parts of the prompt, but provides a lackluster analysis of a foil relationship in The Joy Luck Club. Initially, she doesn't clearly identify what ideas she's going to address in her essay, and it's difficult to follow her train of thought because her thesis statement lacks specificity. She claims that Huang serves as a foil for Lindo, but she doesn't state the characteristics or qualities that are emphasized. Additionally, she says that the relationship between the two characters contributes to the meaning of the literary work, but she doesn't say how. Her first two body paragraphs are basically a summary of The Joy Luck Club that helps the reader become familiar with the relationship between Huang and Lindo, but doesn't explicitly identify how the former is a foil for the latter. She does do a good job of providing evidence for her second claim, however, as she explains how Huang's treatment of Lindo helped her find self-worth in spite of the degradation she was forced to endure. Her conclusion is effective in that it restates her thesis, but like her intro, it's a little too vague. I'd give this student a 5.

Critique #2: This student fails to clearly answer the prompt, beginning with a hastily thrown-together intro paragraph that lacks a defined thesis statement. Interestingly enough, the word "foil" is actually nowhere to be found until the conclusion paragraph, making the purpose of the essay a mystery to all readers. She clearly emphasizes the relationship between Celle and her father from The Color Purple in the first body paragraph, but never actually suggests that one character might be a foil for the other. Instead, she describes the abuse Celle was subjected to at the hands of her father, and the emotional effect it had on her. To deviate even further from the objective, this student's second body paragraph introduces another supporting character, Shug, and describes her relationship with Celle. The student uses comparisons between both Shug and Celle's father to analyze gender roles in the novel, but fails to identify a foil and provide an explanation of it's function in the narrative, as dictated by the prompt. The conclusion finally presents the idea that Celle's father serves a foil to her as she finds her identity, but at that point it's difficult for readers to connect the information in her body paragraphs with this new claim. I'd give this student a 3.

Critique #3: This student very obviously either misunderstood the prompt, or isn't familiar with the term "foil". His basic intro paragraph does contain a rather general thesis statement, but the main issue with the paper lies in his body paragraphs. Firstly, his writing style is rather immature, marked by short sentences and simplistic vocabulary, and indicates a limited ability to use the English language effectively to communicate his ideas, particularly when trying to describe the familial tie between Baba and Hassan of The Kite Runner. This comes through in his body paragraphs, in which he talks primarily about the way Baba and Hassan are similar, despite having just declared Baba a foil for Hassan. The one contrast he does identify, regarding the difference in wealth and popularity between the two characters, doesn't necessarily emphasize the good qualities of Hassan, as this student claimed in his thesis statement. Finally, the conclusion incorrectly addresses the second part of the prompt in a single sentence, highlighting certain qualities the two characters share that coincide with the major themes of the novel, instead of analyzing the function of a foil relationship. I'd give this student a 2.

Sunday, December 8, 2013

Critical Response Essay: Why Mandela Was Unique

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/11/opinion/friedman-why-mandela-was-unique.html?ref=opinion

      The recent passing of Nelson Mandela has resulted in an outpour of reverence and recollection from around the globe. In the wake of his death on December 5, 2013, people everywhere took time to think about the achievements of a truly magnificent individual who used his time on earth to make it a better place. In an op-ed piece for the New York Times, Thomas L. Friedman asks: "why was Mandela unique?" He uses rhetorical techniques like diction, syntax and detail to answer this question and explain how one mankind's greatest leaders earned the love and admiration of the entire world.
      For the most part, Friedman uses colloquial diction in this piece. Seeing as the main purpose of the article was to pay tribute to a great man whose influence spreads far and wide, he avoids using elevated language that may alienate some readers and detract from his overall message. That's not to say Friedman dumbs down his writing style. His diction is careful and expressive, using words like "humility" and "restraint" to identify some of Mandela's key virtues, and describing the South African President's ability "to elevate others". Those words embody Mandela as a human being and a symbol, and help to remind us of his incredible distinction in leadership. Friedman also uses diction to effectively capture the world's reaction to Mandela's passing in his introduction, which reads: "The global outpouring of respect for Nelson Mandela suggests that we're not just saying goodbye to the man at his death, but that were losing a certain kind of leader, unique on the world stage today, and we are mourning that just as much."His choice of the words "outpouring" and "mourning" help to communicate the magnitude of the world's loss.
      Syntactical elements are also instrumental in Friedman's attempt to examine a true global icon. For example, parallel structure creates a rhythm that adds a certain gravitas to his line: "It is easy to lead by telling your own base what it wants to hear. It is easy to lead by giving things away. It is easy to lead when things are going well". This parallelism builds momentum and makes it even more affecting when Friedman discusses Mandela's rejection of what was easy in order to do what was right.  In addition to that, syntax also plays a big part in expressing the terrible obstacles that Mandela struggled against in his lifetime. Friedman describes the the "bitter, entrenched, white rule" that black South Africans faced during Apartheid. The use of asyndeton here places a special emphasis on the word "entrenched", which further express the hopeless situation of the South African people during that time.
      Through the inclusion of relevant detail, Friedman heightens the emotional and intellectual affect of his piece by providing a bit of context. For example, he includes a brief summary of the film Invictus in order to establish a historical background for his discussion of Mandela's achievements during his first year as President. This facilitates a better understanding of the man and his choices in the face of a nation still divided by deeply-rooted prejudice and a desire for retribution. Friedman also consulted with political consultant Dov Siedman for the article, who provided some valuable detail in the form of a comparison between Mandela's political style and that of today's politicians. Siedman comments that "so much of American politics today is about how I narrowcast to this poll-tested demographic in this ZIP code to get just enough voters to shift to my side to give me 50.1 percent...Mandela's leadership genius was his ability to enlist a critical mass of South Africans to elevate, to go to a new place, not just shift a few votes at the margin". Through this apt juxtaposition, Mandela's unique value to the global community is revealed
      Through his use of rhetorical techniques like diction, syntax and detail, Friedman was able to pen a fitting tribute to a leader who's passing reminds us that the work he did for humanity lives on forever.

Sunday, November 24, 2013

Response to Course Material: November

This month, my classmates and I were introduced to a new exercise designed to expand our understanding of how writers use language to create mood and atmosphere. Our task was to choose a digital image from a wide variety, identify a word that describes it's mood perfectly, and then collectively write a description of the image without using said word. Then, we had to defend our creation of mood using specific DIDL examples from our description. It will presumably prove helpful as we prepare for the AP exam, and so far it's made for a great discussion stimulator. Trying to find a perfectly descriptive word for a visual image is no easy task, and our understanding of the power of diction has developed as a result. The fact that we were provided with a limited vocabulary from which to choose forced us to recognize and respond to the little nuances of language that can make all the difference when trying to create mood. We've done exercises similar to this in earlier language arts courses, but the added charge of defending our description turned this into a fresh learning experience. Having to go back and validate our work helped us to realize exactly what it was (syntactical elements, diction, imagery, etc.), that created the mood we were going for. I've been applying these skills to my reading of Hamlet in class, and The Hobbit at home. The exercise inspired me to pay closer attention to literary techniques that Shakespeare and Tolkien use to create their own atmospheres, and how they function within the piece in terms of its overall meaning.
      In addition to that, the vast majority of our November class time has been devoted to completing our discussions of Death of a Salesman and reading Hamlet. My S&A blog post for Salesman already presents the products of our in-class discussion, so I'll refer all readers to it for that. However, I think the style of discussion we experimented with this month is definitely worth mentioning. Since the beginning of November, our formerly socratic discussions morphed into "Goldfish Bowl" discussions. This entailed that up to four students sat in the middle and shared their opinions and interpretations while the rest of the class silently listened. Other students could then enter the discussion by switching places with one of the original "goldfish". I found that this type of discussion helped us uncover meaning more quickly, because we were only able to share our ideas once we had thought them over carefully and found an opportune time to enter the bowl. This way, our class was able to avoid irrelevant chatter and dig deeply into the text. In American Literature two years ago, Mrs. Reed set up discussions for Great Gatsby in a similar way, but they were relatively ineffective because the level of interest in the material was lower in that classroom. By contrast, our AP Lit. class has no shortage of students eager to get involved in discussion, and I think we've greatly benefited from this new method. Outside of the classroom, I could see employers utilizing a similar method of discussion to engage committees or project teams and inspire greater productivity in their workplace.
      Once we wrapped up Salesman, Hamlet loomed large as the next literary obstacle to be tackled by our class. Having just finished our preliminary reading, I can say that it's no surprise that many consider Shakespeare's tale of a deeply-conflicted Danish prince to be the greatest play of all time. It truly is an incredibly influential and deliciously complex piece of literature that is both overwhelming and exciting to me as a first-time reader with a somewhat limited background knowledge of Shakespeare's works. It certainly is less accessible than Romeo and Juliet, which we read freshman year, and I think analyzing it will prove to be quite challenging, especially since all of our reading so far has been in a more contemporary version of English. However, I can't wait to uncover more of Hamlet's range of influence as we delve into our discussion. Coming into the course, I had recently learned of the parallels many had drawn between the play and Disney's The Lion King. Thus, the Bard's infiltration of the family film genre was revealed to me. As I become better acquainted with the piece, it will be interesting to identify what other realms of popular culture its themes and archetypes appear in.
     
   

Sunday, November 17, 2013

Open Prompt Critique (#3)

(2006 Prompt, Question #3: "Country Setting as a Source of Values")

Critique #1: This student crafts a complete essay that responds directly to the prompt in an insightful way. She begins well, acknowledging a counter-argument in her thesis statement, and then effectively presenting her own position in contrast. This technique provides a certain clarity to the reader that helps them identify exactly the direction in which the rest of the piece will go. She then carefully separates her claims about setting in Jane Austen's Persuasion into body paragraphs that retain their focus throughout. Her language isn't confusing or contradictory, either, give or take a few grammatical/spelling slip-ups. In addition, she's careful to conclude each body paragraph with a warranting sentence that ties her evidence back to her thesis. Looking at the grader's response, I was legitimately surprised at the students grade of an 8. Personally, I couldn't find any issues significant enough to justify the loss of a point. Perhaps the student could have been more direct in her conclusion. I suppose her focus waivers slightly in the final paragraph, and technically speaking, a more clear restatement of her thesis may have gotten her that last point. Personally, though, I liked the flow of her conclusion, and I think it served it's function of wrapping up her essay and re-hashing her argument. I'd give this student a 9.

Critique #2: This student is only partially effective in answering the entire prompt, and fails to present valuable evidence in a way that highlights it's connection to his thesis statement. In his introductory paragraph, the student establishes the country setting in The Importance of Being Ernest as one of "tranquility", but fails to provide evidence for this claim in any of his body paragraphs. Instead, he mainly focuses on the function of two settings (rural vs. urban) in the comedic process. His first body paragraph is all summary, and doesn't refer to the prompt or the thesis at all, while his only other body paragraph addresses a portion of his thesis, but fails to explain how the country setting serves as a source of values, as delineated in the prompt. The essay received an official score of 6, which I think could've have been raised if the student crafted a more complete thesis statement that made claims according to the prompt, instead of getting distracted by the role of the setting in creating comedy. I think This would have helped to keep the student on track to construct a tighter essay. As it is though, I'd give this student no more than a 5.

Critique #3: This student attempts answers the prompt with a unique position, but she provides little relevant evidence and her phrasing is nearly incomprehensible, squandering any potential her essay may have had. Firstly, the student fails to clearly identify a thesis statement that establishes her claims, and the introductory paragraph in general is very vague. The rest of the essay is devoted to explaining how Faulkner used the setting of the south, as morally "backwards" as it is, as a plot device to justify the actions of the bizarre actions of the characters in As I Lay Dying. While this claim, were it clearly identified, would be an effective answer to the prompt, the textual evidence included by the student fails to reinforce the rural setting as a source of values. Instead, she focuses on the strange behavior of the characters and provides inadequate warrants back to her essentially non-existent thesis statement. This student received a score of 4, which honestly seems a little generous. I think the student could have benefited from spending more time on the organization of her thoughts, as well as her construction of warrants. The root of the problem, however, seems to be her lack of a real thesis statement, which generally serves as the cornerstone of a writer's argument. I'd give this student a 3.

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Summary and Analysis: Death of a Salesman

      As one of America's most influential dramatists, Arthur Miller's contributions to the western literary canon have been tremendous. Born in New York City in 1915, Miller discovered his aptitude for playwriting during his studies at the University of Michigan. Following his graduation in 1938, Miller went on to write what would become his first commercial success, the drama All My Sons. The play revealed Miller's obsession with the "American Dream", a concept that he would continue to explore in much of his later work. Following up on that success, Miller penned Death of a Salesman, the play that would come to define him for future generations. In his masterpiece, Miller comments on the eventual self-destruction that can result from valuing the power of words over actions in the pursuit of conventional success. He also suggests that a loss of dignity and a devastation of familial relationships are inevitable byproducts of such a lopsided philosophy. In the timeless character of misguided everyman Willy Loman, Miller pays tribute to a bygone version of the American Dream, while shining a harsh light on modern times. 
      The play opens with Willy Loman's return to his modest, single-family home in a neighborhood of Brooklyn, New York. The traditional American middle-class setting that surrounds the action of the play helps to emphasize the  averageness of the Loman clan. As the narrative unfolds, this heightens a sense of sad irony, as Miller's woebegone protagonist yearns desperately for greatness. Before any dialogue is shared between character's, it's clear that Willy is a man running on empty. As a traveling salesman, he has lived his life by a special creed, a deeply rooted belief in the power of human relationships and the sense of trust that is such a vital part of them. As the years have gone by, Willy hasn't achieved the success he expected for himself based off of his constant determination to be "well-liked." In a conversation with his wife Linda regarding their mortgage payments early in the first act, Willy glumly states, "Figure it out. Work a lifetime to pay off a house. You finally own it, and there's nobody to live in it"(Miller 4). The line perfectly summarizes his disappointment with life, while connecting it to a sense of materialism that is so closely associated with the image of conventional success that he deeply desires. This mounting dissatisfaction has taken a toll on Willy--who's now in his sixties--and by the time the play begins, his dignity has taken a serious hit. As a result, his mind has begun to wander into the past, where is able to find temporary joy in memories of more hopeful times and search for the root of all of his sorrow. His wife, Linda Loman, struggles to protect what is left of his sense of self-respect while encouraging him to accept his life for what it is. The "loving" relationship between her and her husband has grown increasingly one-sided  as Willy's image of his future achievements has failed to materialize. On top of that, their two sons, Biff and Happy, who Willy looked at as a sort of saving grace, haven't amounted to much since they left home. Miller's portrayal of a troubling family dynamic held together by tenuous relationships sends a powerful message regarding a man's ability to take care of his family in the face of crushing disappointment. 
      As the story progresses, we learn that Biff, Willy's favorite son, has returned home from a ranching job out west. We also learn that he's brought back with him a sense of bitterness towards his father that has severely weakened the bond they once had. Through a series of flashbacks, this former bond is revealed, along with the way in which Willy raised his sons. In an impossibly idyllic vision of a moment in the family's past, Willy boosts Biff's confidence before a champion football game that has the potential to turn him into a great success. It it is here that Willy's philosophical imbalance becomes apparent. He's all talk,  boasting of his dubious business achievements and inflating the egos of his two sons, even at the expense of Biff's smaller, weaker and less-liked friend, Bernard. Bernard, a studious and responsible young man, serves as a foil to Biff, who has been spoiled by his father's pride and an assurance that "the man who creates personal interest, is the man who gets ahead"(Miller 21). This line encapsulates Willy's belief in style over substance, in words over actions. According to him, the man who can convince enough people of his greatness will be great. With this advice and a constant stream of praise, Willy sets his well-built progeny up for failure. Later in the play, we discover that Willy has passed down a propensity for lying to his sons, a detail that further emphasizes the unreliable nature of words as tools with which to achieve success. 
      In the second act, Willy grapples with his misguidance following a brutal encounter with reality. Encouraged by his wife and a sense of crippling weariness, Willy asks his young boss, Howard, for a different position stationed closer to home. He expects his wish to be granted based off of a couple of absent-minded promises and a friendly relationship he had with Howard's father, who owned the company up until his death. Howard initially blows off Willy's requests due to his fixation with a tape-recorder, and eventually fires him all together. Thusly, Willy comes to realize the minimal value that his reputation holds in the face of a modern American business world based around new principles that don't honor old promises or affinities. When Willy proclaims, "You can't eat the orange and throw the peel away---a man is not a piece of fruit!"(Miller 62), he is expressing his complete disbelief in this modern approach to business, and revealing a fundamental misunderstanding of the world that has led to his own failure and the dysfunction of his family. 
      Meanwhile, Biff's relationships with his mother and his brother are strained as he pits his own resentment towards his father against their undying love and admiration for him. As Willy returns on his mental voyage through the past, we finally discover the source of that resentment.  In the realm of Willy's mind, we watch Biff--looking for his dad to bail him out of a failed class with some smooth-talking--walk in on Willy and a mysterious woman in a Boston hotel room. In that moment, Biff's world turns upside down. He breaks into sobs as he realizes that his idol betrayed him--by betraying his mother--and that he can no longer pursue the dreams that Willy had for him. By catching his father in such a serious lie, Biff's faith in him and all of his wisdom is permanently shaken. So much so, in fact, that he gives up on school and abandons his athletic scholarships, choosing instead to move west and adopt a lifestyle different in almost every way to the one that Willy had hoped for him to have. Back in the present, Willy returns home with a packet of seeds, a meager representation of the investment he made in his son, and a conflicted mindset. He consults with a memory of his brother Ben, a conventionally successful man that Willy admired greatly in life. Ben had made appearances in flashbacks throughout the play, deified in Willy's memory, providing enigmatic answers to Willy's constant question's regarding the key to success. The brothers talk business regarding the idea of committing suicide in order to claim a twenty-thousand dollar life insurance policy. Willy sees it as his only opportunity to provide Biff with something to make up for destroying his faith. He recognizes it as a last hope for success, because with "twenty thousand behind him" he still believes Biff can be "magnificent". In a way, the seeds Willy brought home represent a resilient feeling of hope amidst all the despair of his own failure. 
    Shortly thereafter, Biff confronts Willy, explaining to his decaying father that he's leaving New York. What starts as a calm parting of ways becomes a furious ideological exchange in which Biff cries, "Pop! I'm a dime a dozen, and so are you!"(Miller 105). This exhausted exclamation represents Biff's total rejection of his father's belief system, and his emotional need to separate himself from the man and the ideas that have hindered his own self-discovery. The verbal sparring match ends in tears and reconciliation, as Biff proclaims his identity through sobs at his father's feet, Willy takes this display of emotion as much-needed assurance of his son's love for him. As everyone goes to bed, the narrative ends with Willy, inspired by his brother Ben's words and convinced he is doing the right thing for Biff and the rest of the family, killing himself in the name of greatness.
      All the meaning that can be derived from the plot and characters is given greater complexity and depth with Miller's use of literary techniques. For example, Willy's frequent use of elevated diction, combined with his socio-economic status and his education level, gave him an air of falsity, and emphasized the motif of "words over action" that is so frequently associated with his character. Additionally, objects like the tape-recorder in Howard's office and the packet of seeds are heavily symbolic. Miller uses dialogue and stage instructions to create tonal shifts when necessary throughout the play. 
      
      

Sunday, November 10, 2013

Critical Response Essay: Is It O.K. to Kill Cyclists?

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/10/opinion/sunday/is-it-ok-to-kill-cyclists.html?_r=0&adxnnl=1&ref=opinion&pagewanted=2&adxnnlx=1384109837-Cl0T5PBWM6z0/EMgDinWxg


      In recent years, bicycling has grown in popularity as a mode of transportation and a form of exercise. However, American drivers have struggled to safely and respectfully share the roads with commuters and fitness enthusiasts who prefer bicycles, which lack the degree of physical protection offered by larger vehicles. Injury and death has frequently resulted from poor cooperation between these two rival demographics, and those behind the wheel rarely face serious legal consequences. In his opinion piece written for The New York Times, titled: "Is It O.K. to Kill Cyclists?", Daniel Duane uses rhetorical techniques like diction, imagery and detail to communicate the absurdity of this injustice faced by cyclists.
      Throughout the piece, Duane utilizes a blend of colloquial and formal diction to establish his credibility while avoiding an air of pretension, and to effectively express his position in a way that is accessible to a wide range of readers. Words like "meagerness" and "negligence" color the piece with linguistic variety, while slang terms like "hipster" and "fixie" give the piece cultural relevance that a larger audience can identify with. More specifically, however, he uses careful word choice to express his disbelief over a questionable pattern of legal behavior. For example, Duane aptly states, "there is something undeniably screwy about a justice system that makes it de facto legal to kill people." His use of the word "screwy" conveys a sense of illogic, that not only makes this flaw in our justice system seem wrong, but downright preposterous.

      Duane also employs imagery as an intriguing opener for his appeal to our common sense.  Recounting a particularly perilous bike ride, he writes "I watched an SUV driver hit another cyclist, and then I got my own front wheel caught in a streetcar track, sending me to the pavement." This image of misfortune draws readers in by providing an exaggerated example of the dangers faced by cyclists. Considering the controversial and emotionally-charged nature of this issue, using language to illustrate tragic loss and the injustice that inevitably follows is also a particularly effective tool for building a strong position. For example, Duane creates a disturbing image by writing "If your 13-year-old daughter bikes to school tomorrow inside a freshly painted bike lane, and a driver runs a stop sign and kills her and then says to the cop, 'Gee, I so totally did not mean to do that,' that will most likely be good enough." By placing an image of innocence into the minds of his readers in the form of a young girl, Duane opens us up to emotional response. Subsequently, he is able to effectively elicit that sort of response by subjecting that image to the sort of injustice that many cyclists who are probably equally innocent--but less cute--unfortunately experience. 
     Additionally, Duane provides scads of detail to help strengthen his position. He includes an interesting quote from "bike law" attorney Ray Thomas that shines some light on the legal process surrounding a car/bike accident. According to Thomas "'jurors identify with drivers...they just think, well, I could make the same mistake. So they don't convict.'" This sort of relevant detail helps to validate Duane's argument by bringing up the jury's role in the issue. Because of the mandatory involvement of American citizens in jury duty, readers can relate to this information, and therefore become more actively engaged in his argument. On top of that, Duane included a real-life example of prejudice towards cyclists in their struggle for their share of the road. His anecdote about Sgt. Ernst and Ms. Le Moullac revealed a degree of indifference by the police toward the plight of wounded cyclists. Duane's incorporation of a specific instance in which proper consequences weren't appropriated to a guilty driver helps express the reality of a problem that touches everyone, whether you're behind the wheel or the handlebars. 
      Through his use of diction, imagery and detail, among other rhetorical techniques, Daniel Duane is able to spread awareness of a serious injustice, the repercussions of which are being felt by more and more as many Americans begin to adopt a new, two-wheeled lifestyle.  
   
         

Sunday, October 27, 2013

Response to Course Material: October

This October has been, by-and-large, a great one--particularly in the AP Lit. classroom. We've occupied the better portion of our time together this month exploring Death of a Salesman, a fascinating and timeless member of the American literary canon, and a play that is quickly becoming one of my personal favorites. Through our absorption and discussion of the text, along with the guidance of Ms. Holmes, we've been able to expand our literary knowledge to include ancient concepts like the definition of Tragedy, as well as the modern author's response to such firmly established institutions. We've also had some opportunities to apply our close-reading techniques, both to Salesman and to a number of poetry selections including "My Father's Song" and "Promises Like Pie Crust". On top of all that, we even managed to squeeze in a little AP multiple choice practice, which has made me feel all the more confident for that ominous date in May.
      As we began to analyze Death of A Salesman following our individual close readings, we were confronted with the difficult question of it's classification. More specifically, was it true tragedy--in the original sense of the word? Ms. Holmes primed the pump with a number of relevant articles including "Tragedy and The Common Man" by Arthur Miller himself. Miller presented the idea that tragedy as genre has evolved to encompass a broader range of human struggle to which modern readers can relate. In contrast to Miller's argument, we know that "Tragedy" is a term refined by centuries of scholarly debate, and while he may have utilized tragic elements in the crafting of his tale, Salesman can't be called a tragedy unless it meets the original criteria. and  After a few days of class discussion, we were still divided regarding the plays status as a tragedy, but I realized how our application of close reading helped us identify different tragic elements present within the text and thusly develop our own conclusions. It was equally enlightening to use the same methods to pull meaning out of the poetry we read as well. The universal nature of close-reading as a tool for analysis really dawned on me this month, especially after uncovering the themes and of motifs of "Promises like Pie Crust".  I particularly enjoyed the poem by Christina Rossetti, mainly because of the satisfaction I gained from recognizing all the little nuances hidden in it's stanzas. As another testament to the value of close-reading, the multiple choice samples we worked on required an in-depth technical examination of a literary passage, similar to what we were doing at home with Salesman. Identifying meaningful uses of diction, syntax, language, etc. helped us determine the themes and motifs that were used to convey meaning from Ulysses's soliloquy in Shakespeare's Troilus and Cressida.
      Reflecting back on our October learning experiences, what sticks with me most is the way in which seemingly insignificant literary techniques can speak volumes about the meaning of a text, and how this necessitates a careful examination following the guidelines of the familiar and omnipresent acronym that is "DIDLS". Let's just say that after this month, I will no longer hesitate to mark up that pristine first page of a new novel, knowing that the key to my understanding of it's content lies in my ability to identify and interpret all the little techniques, right there in the margins.
   











Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompt Critique (#2)

(2009 Prompt, Question #1: "Shakespeares Henry VIII, Cardinal Wolsey's Speech")

Critique #1: This student manages to address all parts of the prompt and, in a general sense, produces a well-crafted essay based around a strong thesis. After a brief and intelligent introduction, the student is quick to establish the topic of her essay with a solid thesis statement that emphasizes the complexity of Wolsey's emotional reaction in the passage, a point that was stressed in the rubric. She also provides a number of techniques that Shakespeare used to express said complexity, which is an essential step in thoroughly responding to the prompt. The student's only real issue is a partial lack of effective warrants. For example, his/her usage of Wolsey's flower metaphor, while relevant to the topic of the essay, doesn't directly relate to the claims made in the thesis. The student makes a lot of good points regarding Shakespeare's techniques, but isn't always successful in explaining how those techniques conveyed Wolsey's anger and lamentation. That's not to say the student doesn't provide any acceptable warrants, by any means. Her apt recognition of a tonal shift in Wolsey's speech redeems that portion of the essay, particularly after it's masterfully related to the complexity of Wolsey's response. I'd give this student an 8, maybe even a 9.

Critique #2: This student approaches his topic with a carefully-phrased introduction that effectively outlines her perception of Wolsey's reaction. Though her thesis was less cut and dry than that of the first essay, the student makes up for any minimal lack of clarity in her wording with an impressive fluency. The first body paragraph includes a thoughtful example of how extended metaphor ("the killing frost") is used to communicate Wolsey's emotions, and the student effectively relates it back to the thesis, citing the philosophical sadness of the line in order to support her claim regarding Wolsey's initial despair. Unfortunately, the student runs into trouble in the second body paragraph. Here, the piece basically degenerates into a string of quotes, without enough reasonable explanation for the inclusion of each in between. It seems as though the student fails to come up with sufficient support for the thesis after her first body paragraph, and thusly resorts to listing the various techniques employed by Shakespeare in the passage, regardless of whether or not they support her claims about Wolsey's emotional reaction. For the majority of the essay, the quality of content isn't able to match the student's skillful phrasing. I'd give this student a 5.

Critique #3: This student's essay is rife with continuity issues. Her relatively weak thesis statement, which fails to thoroughly comment on the complexity of Wolsey's response, isn't supported by the rest of her essay. In fact, she concludes it by describing Wolsey's reaction as furious and hysterical, when her thesis makes note of the bitterness and grief present in his response to his dismissal. Also, the student bases her seemingly random claims off of a confused and contradictory interpretation of the better half of Wolsey's speech. For example, she sees Wolsey's lamentation of the human condition to be an indication his eagerness to exact revenge on those who wronged him, a shallow interpretation that overlooks some of the more harrowing themes that Shakespeare probably meant to introduce in this passage. On top of that, the student fails to clearly identify the techniques being explored in each paragraph, making it even more difficult to determine the validity of her claims and warrants. Complete with limited fluency and a number of obvious grammatical and spelling errors, the essay fails to adequately respond to the prompt in a comprehensive way. I'd give this student a 3.


Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Summary and Analysis: The American Dream

      In Edward Albee, American society found one of it's most thoughtful critics. Born in 1928, the young playwright had his first one-act play published in 1959. His work dealt with broad, gripping themes like societal conformity and family dynamics, and achieved critical acclaim early on. In 1960, Albee completed and published The American Dream, an enigmatic piece that intrigued readers and producers alike. The disturbing cross-section of the modern American condition recognized the gradual deterioration of that which used to define the nation. Albee's fourth play warned readers that the current generation of Americans were gutting the heart and soul of traditional American values and replacing them with a materialistic longing to acquire unattainable satisfaction. The absurdist elements utilized by Albee to represent the social confusion being experienced by the nation eventually helped propel this masterpiece into the the American literary canon.
      The narrative unfolds in a curiously symmetrical--yet otherwise nondescript--apartment in an unidentified city. This "Anytown, USA" setting helps to communicate the universally American nature of the play's message. Right away, we're introduced to the characters of Mommy and Daddy, a married couple with a seemingly unconventional relationship. Mommy requires complete submission of her spouse, so much that she effectively emasculates Daddy--in more ways than one. Mommy provides a prime example of her dominating persona when she says to Daddy, "I have a right to live off of you because I married you, and because I used to let you get on top of me and bump your uglies; and I have a right to all your money when you die."(Albee 67) This line clearly outlines Albee's message regarding traditional American gender roles. He makes it look as though men are in eternal debt to women as soon as they enter into marriage, which emphasizes the emergence of a stronger, domineering role for the female in modern American society. This represents one of the significant departures from traditional American standards around which Albee's play is built. Mommy's quote also exemplifies a new materialistic longing that Albee suggests has become central to the values of modern America. Mommy's emphasis on money and consumerism, not only in the line above ("I have a right to all your money when you die), but throughout the play symbolizes the American peoples' new infatuation with everything that's expensive, fashionable, and fancier than their neighbor's. In fact Mommy's materialistic vision of the ideal family inspired her and Daddy to purchase a child, a "bumble" whom they later mutilate and murder after not being able to gain any satisfaction from their relationship with him. Their actions put the events of the play into motion, and ultimately account for the creation of a new set of American values based around materialism. In addition, Mommy's particular embroilment in the consumer culture, highlighted in her lengthy discussion with Daddy about a trivial hat purchase, indicates Albee's suggestion that modern gender dynamics have inspired the materialistic movement, led largely by women.
      As the narrative progresses, the character of Grandma enters the story, and we're presented with two different yet equally vital relationships that speak volumes about the meaning of the play. Grandma is the mother of Mommy, and is a considerably older character than her and Daddy, and thusly subscribes to a more traditional set of values. She has been essentially cast off by Mommy, and therefore somewhat disregarded by Daddy as well. Because of her inability and refusal to conform to the modern societal standards, she is rendered valueless in the eyes of Mommy, who initially keeps up false pretenses around her mother in order to preserve her image of a normal, happy family. Though Daddy generally complies with Mommy's wishes, he occasionally sticks up for Grandma later on--even if that means just apologizing for his or his wife's behavior--because secretly he can identify with her traditional values more than Mommy's materialistic ideology. When Grandma (in response to an apology from Daddy) says, "Well that's all that counts. People being sorry. Makes you feel better; gives you a sense of dignity, and that's all that's important...a sense of dignity"(Albee 64), we can see that things like dignity and other virtues are more important to her than wealth and physical actractiveness, the sorts of things that Mommy values most highly.
     Albee manifests his central idea that the "American Dream" isn't what it once was in the character of the Young Man. He arrives just as Grandma is about to leave the apartment, sick of the abuse and ignorance she encounters with Mommy. The Young Man is, essentially, the complete opposite of Grandma, who readers have to come to associate with the "American Dream" of a bygone time, as she is of "pioneer stock". His intense physical attractiveness, combined with his lack of any talent or virtue, and topped off with his insatiable hunger for wealth, makes him the ideal foil to Grandma's down-to-earth idealism. When the Young Man says "I have no talents at all, except what you see...my person; my body, my face. In every other way I am incomplete..."(Albee 113) he emphasizes his lack of any real substance. The fact that the Young Man is so fundamentally flawed indicates Albee's belief that the new American longing for a materialistic happiness will not provide legitimate or permanent satisfaction.
     Just as the plot and characters of the play create meaning, so do the literary techniques used by Albee to tell the story. For example, Albee's use of very informal diction and frequent childish slang terms infantilize his characters, drawing a sadly apt comparison between the American people and babies. The names of the characters ("Mommy", "Daddy") reinforce this comparison. Albee also includes a great amount of repitition and cyclical phrasing in this in order to emphasize the lack of original thought or sense of priority in the younger generation of Americans. For example, Mommy and Daddy's constant focus on the lateness of their visitor makes them seem impatient and uninteresting.  The combination of these literary techniques, including the use of symbols like Grandma's boxes (the values of the "Old American Dream") and the emphasis on literal meaning (Daddy's emasculation was evidenced by an actual sex change) inspires many critics to label it as an absurdist-style play. On one level, the meaning associated with the text disqualifies it from that category. In another way, however, the absurdity of the events in the play represent the chaos of social confusion in America during the time the play was published, as a result of a significant shift in societal values.

Sunday, October 13, 2013

Critical Response Essay: These Evangelicals Hate Gays So Much, Life Isn't Worth Living Anymore



http://www.policymic.com/articles/67465/these-evangelicals-hate-gays-so-much-life-isn-t-worth-living-anymore

      As the issue of gay rights continues to permeate our political discussions, groups on the both sides have begun to voice their more radical opinions in hopes of swaying the American majority. In this article, Pierre-Guy Veer focuses on the disturbing ideas of those who condemn homosexuality in the name of religion. He uses rhetorical elements like diction, syntax, and detail to present and criticize the "bigoted" claims of homophobic Evangelicals.
      Throughout the piece, Veer voices his opinions with informal diction. This helps to make the piece feel conversational, and gives it a natural flow that draws in readers. For example, Veer's first line: "Christian conservatives in the U.S. say the darnedest things"(Veer) parodies the common expression, "kids say the darnedest things", a humorous bit of wordplay that provides readers with a simple, familiar phrase while communicating his disapproval of religious extremism. While his use of diction helps to draw readers in, it also establishes a passionate tone for the piece that indicates how strongly Veer feels about the topic. He refers to the Christian conservative rhetoric as "old, bigoted, intolerant nonsense"(Veer). Harsh language such as that makes the piece feel almost like an invective, and in this way, Veer clearly distinguishes his op-ed piece from other fact-based articles.
      In addition to diction, syntactical choices made by Veer had a significant effect on the expression of his opinion. His relentless criticism of Christian conservatives is highlighted by the driving and repetitive arrangement of his phrasing. For example, Veer starts a number of his sentences with the words "if they", "they" or "their", referring to the Evangelicals. He often finishes the sentence with an example of their bigotry, or a mocking suggestion like the following: "If they are so unhappy in Western countries, then surely they can go elsewhere"(Veer). This form of sentence construction gives the piece an accusatory feel that very clearly communicates Veer's opinion. He also employs parallel syntax to perform a similar role in the text. Veer says, "There is no homosexual lifestyle...and there is no gay agenda"(Veer). The two sentences are paired together by their near identical beginnings, the declaratory nature of which helps to hammer Veer's point home and convince readers of his passion for the topic and his confidence in his critique of Evangelical homophobia.
      Detail also plays a significant role in strengthening Veer's criticism. He uses specific examples of claims made by radical Christian conservatives to expose their absurd ideology to his readers and thusly justify his criticism. For example, he cited a Winston Churchill quote about The Second World War used by a prominent Evangelical activist group to emphasize their disturbing application of it to their own fight against equal rights. The inclusion of such detail provides support for his admonishment of conservative social ideology.  Veer also suggests that "they could go to the Arabian Peninsula, where homosexuality is punishable by death. However, non-muslims, when not persecuted, are totally unfree, especially in cases of apostasy"(Veer). This information regarding backwards global conditions strengthens his argument by highlighting the hypocrisy of Evangelicals, proving that in a place where one group is so harshly persecuted, no one truly enjoys the benefits of freedom. This level of detail throughout the piece helps to expose the intolerance of radical Evangelicals and justify Veer's criticism of them.
      Veer's piece functions not only as a much-needed attack on the enemies of human rights, but also as a prime example of how literary techniques can help communicate the message of a piece. Thanks to his use of diction, syntax and detail, Veer was able to effectively present the claims and ideology of radical Christian conservatives, and subsequently invalidate them with a nice dose of reality.



Sunday, September 29, 2013

Response to Course Material: September

          Throughout the beginning of the year and our recent reading and discussion of The American Dream, I have begun to wrap my head around broad concepts like Existentialism and Theater of the Absurd, while also learning how strong DIDLS can be applied to a text in order to make it more effective at conveying meaning.
          Before taking this course, I had not encountered a play--or any type of literature--stylistically similar to Dream. Seemingly nonsensical, I was skeptical but also intrigued after our first reading. The essays we read on Theater of the Absurd and Existentialism highlighted some of the key points of both fields, like the idea that the universe is inexplicable, and that humans are wholly responsible for their fate based on their decisions.  These essays really helped me to look harder at a play that initially appeared to be a jumble of weird dialogue and dirty jokes. I began to recognize some of the bizarre dialogue and stage directions to be, in a broad sense, an existentialist commentary on the triumph of social approval and structure over the traditional values that make us who we are. Ervin Beck and Philip C. Kolin helped identify the connection between Theatre of the Absurd, a classification that many critics assign Dream, and the existentialist philosophy present in it. Thanks to some of their ideas, I came to the understanding that "Theater of the Absurd" is a label given to dramatic pieces that are essentially void of meaning, in which lack of any real plot or message represents "man's attempt to make sense for himself out of his senseless position in a world which makes no sense."(Beck 1) After grasping this, we, as a class, came to the conclusion  that Dream didn't quite fit that categorization. Although it does contain some of the existential ideas that Theater of the Absurd pieces attempt to communicate, we determined that it definitely has meaning beyond that, and a narrative rife with symbolism and other figurative elements that support a central message on top of  "the universe is senseless", which is what we get from TotA pieces by the likes of Samuel Beckett and Eugene Lonesco.
           Reading The American Dream not only helped us hone our conceptual understanding, but gave us an opportunity to practice "close reading". We learned this technique at the beginning of the year, along with it's corresponding acronym: DIDLS. Diction, Imagery, Details, Language, and Syntax are the five major elements of close reading analysis, and we focused on them when reading Dream. With regards to Albee's diction in the play, he used both informal and colloquial diction. At times, this made his dialogue feel aggravatingly American, like something was amiss, and helped emphasize some of his characters' horrid personalities. His imagery, with regards to the set description and dialogue, gave the play a bizarre, inhuman feel. The ways in which he had his characters behaving and the images their dialogue inspired set up a disconnect between the readers and the characters that helped highlight their warped sense of morals. Through his use of these and other literary techniques in Dream, Albee gave additional support to the concepts around which he based his message.
         With these and other close reading observations, along with our in-class discussions, I was able to take more away from The American Dream than any other piece of literature I've read. Now as I'm annotating the piece, I'm finding myself able to draw some of my own conclusions thanks to the skills we've begun to develop as a class, and it's got me really excited for the rest of they year.

Sunday, September 22, 2013

Open Prompt Critique

(2008 Prompt, Question #3: "Function of a Foil")

Critique #1: This student answers both parts of the prompt, but provides a lackluster analysis of a foil relationship in The Joy Luck Club. Initially, she doesn't clearly identify what ideas she's going to address in her essay, and it's difficult to follow her train of thought because her thesis statement lacks specificity. She claims that Huang serves as a foil for Lindo, but she doesn't state the characteristics or qualities that are emphasized. Additionally, she says that the relationship between the two characters contributes to the meaning of the literary work, but she doesn't say how. Her first two body paragraphs are basically a summary of The Joy Luck Club that helps the reader become familiar with the relationship between Huang and Lindo, but doesn't explicitly identify how the former is a foil for the latter. She does do a good job of providing evidence for her second claim, however, as she explains how Huang's treatment of Lindo helped her find self-worth in spite of the degradation she was forced to endure. Her conclusion is effective in that it restates her thesis, but like her intro, it's a little too vague. I'd give this student a 5.

Critique #2: This student fails to clearly answer the prompt, beginning with a hastily thrown-together intro paragraph that lacks a defined thesis statement. Interestingly enough, the word "foil" is actually nowhere to be found until the conclusion paragraph, making the purpose of the essay a mystery to all readers. She clearly emphasizes the relationship between Celle and her father from The Color Purple in the first body paragraph, but never actually suggests that one character might be a foil for the other. Instead, she describes the abuse Celle was subjected to at the hands of her father, and the emotional effect it had on her. To deviate even further from the objective, this student's second body paragraph introduces another supporting character, Shug, and describes her relationship with Celle. The student uses comparisons between both Shug and Celle's father to analyze gender roles in the novel, but fails to identify a foil and provide an explanation of it's function in the narrative, as dictated by the prompt. The conclusion finally presents the idea that Celle's father serves a foil to her as she finds her identity, but at that point it's difficult for readers to connect the information in her body paragraphs with this new claim. I'd give this student a 3.

Critique #3: This student very obviously either misunderstood the prompt, or isn't familiar with the term "foil". His basic intro paragraph does contain a rather general thesis statement, but the main issue with the paper lies in his body paragraphs. Firstly, his writing style is rather immature, marked by short sentences and simplistic vocabulary, and indicates a limited ability to use the English language effectively to communicate his ideas, particularly when trying to describe the familial tie between Baba and Hassan of The Kite Runner. This comes through in his body paragraphs, in which he talks primarily about the way Baba and Hassan are similar, despite having just declared Baba a foil for Hassan. The one contrast he does identify, regarding the difference in wealth and popularity between the two characters, doesn't necessarily emphasize the good qualities of Hassan, as this student claimed in his thesis statement. Finally, the conclusion incorrectly addresses the second part of the prompt in a single sentence, highlighting certain qualities the two characters share that coincide with the major themes of the novel, instead of analyzing the function of a foil relationship. I'd give this student a 2.

Sunday, September 15, 2013

Critical Response Essay: In the End, New Yorkers Reject Bad Boy Candidates

http://ideas.time.com/2013/09/11/in-the-end-new-yorkers-reject-bad-boy-candidates/

Scandalous politicians have been on a roll in the city of New York this past year, and a flood of opinion pieces have been published in response. In this article, Time contributor Errol Louis uses rhetorical elements like diction, language, and details to comment on the absurdity of his hometown's political scene, while concurrently providing readers with an explanation.
      Firstly, Louis's use of colloquial diction makes his article accessible to the average reader, which is imperative in order for it's message to hit home. After all, the piece is ultimately about the diversity of our country's greatest city, and the tolerance that is required of its residents. A universal message like that demands a voice that the people of all walks of life can understand and relate to. He even uses the occasional slang term like "bad boy" to subtly make fun of the politicians under scrutiny, a bit of humor that can draw reader's attention and help them to connect with the meaning of the piece. Even so, he uses diction intelligently enough to communicate his credibility, particularly when providing readers with data from the polls, supporting his claims about New Yorkers' political response.
      Secondly, Louis uses language that highlights the important elements of his message. Words like "paradox"--as used in the first sentence--effectively express his claim that tolerance and acceptance are fundamentally different concepts, an idea that contrasts with our general knowledge of the words, but which further reading reveals to be true. In addition, his frequent use of the term "diversity" challenges our typical understanding of the word. Personally, I generally apply it to ethnic or racial differences, but here Louis uses it to describe the cultural and behavioral differences between people, a usage that is perhaps more appropriate in a country that ought to focus less on the geographical origins of its residents, and more on how they can contribute to their communities. Through language, we notice somewhat of a subtext in the article.
     Thirdly, Louis includes plenty of detail in order to emphasize the difference between people--and between politicians--that makes a level of tolerance so important to everyday life, particularly in a diverse metropolis like NYC. For example, Louis notes how "punk rockers live next door to opera fans" and he even recognizes how LGBTQ societies can occasionally find some common ground with religious groups. By highlighting the ways in which our behaviors differ, he more vividly illustrates his point to his readers.
     Through rhetoric, Errol Louis not only explained why New Yorkers have a tendency to entertain the brash behavior of some of its political icons, but he implied that such tolerance might not be a bad thing after all. In fact, Louis implies, it's probably a direction the entire country should head in--as long as we don't forget how to "quietly reject" the "bad boys"in the end.

Tuesday, August 27, 2013

Poetry Self-Assessment

After doing the poetry practice problems, I got an even better idea about where my strengths lie when it comes to comprehending and analyzing poetry. I know I touched on this topic in my last post, but I definitely think I've discovered some new areas that I'll need to work on this year as well. For one, when I read poetry, I typically focus all my energy on deciphering the message or themes of a poem, and I often disregard its more technical elements. Therefore I sometimes struggle with identifying complex meters or recognizing iambic pentameter. That stuff is all an important part of poetry that I have yet to fully grasp. Additionally, because of the rather cryptic nature of a lot of poetry, I sometimes have difficulty identifying literary devices like metaphors and similes and settle with a more basic understanding of the poem. I feel like this prevents me from being enriched by the poetry and can even be a little frustrating at times. While these weaknesses do concern me as I go into AP Lit, I'm pretty confident that this class will help me broaden my horizons a little, and maybe find ways to overcome the issues I have with studying poetry right now.

Thursday, August 22, 2013

Reflection: Diagnostic Test

Taking the Diagnostic Test gave me some interesting insight with regards to my own literary abilities. I was proud of what I did know, and intrigued by what I did not. Honestly though, I didn't do very well, particularly when it came to the poetry questions. I guess I have an easier time with prose. Question number 30, for example, asked me to identify the type of the given poem, "Night Clouds". As of right now, it's pretty difficult for me to distinguish a sonnet from an ode from an elegy and so on. It turned out to be a lyric. Also, I find it harder to get a good feel on the tone of a poem sometimes if its language is archaic or slang. For this reason, and because I wasn't fairly certain "sanguine" or "sardonic" meant, question number 5 was a bit of a head-scratcher for me. Hopefully this year in AP Lit will give me a little bit more knowledge in the poetic realm. In contrast, I felt a lot more confident when answering the questions responding to the Pride and Prejudice passage. On question 19, I was able to correctly identify a source of irony in the conversation between Mr. and Mrs. Bennet. This doesn't really surprise me, because I've read a lot of novels, but not a lot of poetry in my lifetime. Taking the test helped to prepare me for the type of thinking well be doing in AP Lit, and I think it was a worthwhile assessment.