Sunday, September 29, 2013

Response to Course Material: September

          Throughout the beginning of the year and our recent reading and discussion of The American Dream, I have begun to wrap my head around broad concepts like Existentialism and Theater of the Absurd, while also learning how strong DIDLS can be applied to a text in order to make it more effective at conveying meaning.
          Before taking this course, I had not encountered a play--or any type of literature--stylistically similar to Dream. Seemingly nonsensical, I was skeptical but also intrigued after our first reading. The essays we read on Theater of the Absurd and Existentialism highlighted some of the key points of both fields, like the idea that the universe is inexplicable, and that humans are wholly responsible for their fate based on their decisions.  These essays really helped me to look harder at a play that initially appeared to be a jumble of weird dialogue and dirty jokes. I began to recognize some of the bizarre dialogue and stage directions to be, in a broad sense, an existentialist commentary on the triumph of social approval and structure over the traditional values that make us who we are. Ervin Beck and Philip C. Kolin helped identify the connection between Theatre of the Absurd, a classification that many critics assign Dream, and the existentialist philosophy present in it. Thanks to some of their ideas, I came to the understanding that "Theater of the Absurd" is a label given to dramatic pieces that are essentially void of meaning, in which lack of any real plot or message represents "man's attempt to make sense for himself out of his senseless position in a world which makes no sense."(Beck 1) After grasping this, we, as a class, came to the conclusion  that Dream didn't quite fit that categorization. Although it does contain some of the existential ideas that Theater of the Absurd pieces attempt to communicate, we determined that it definitely has meaning beyond that, and a narrative rife with symbolism and other figurative elements that support a central message on top of  "the universe is senseless", which is what we get from TotA pieces by the likes of Samuel Beckett and Eugene Lonesco.
           Reading The American Dream not only helped us hone our conceptual understanding, but gave us an opportunity to practice "close reading". We learned this technique at the beginning of the year, along with it's corresponding acronym: DIDLS. Diction, Imagery, Details, Language, and Syntax are the five major elements of close reading analysis, and we focused on them when reading Dream. With regards to Albee's diction in the play, he used both informal and colloquial diction. At times, this made his dialogue feel aggravatingly American, like something was amiss, and helped emphasize some of his characters' horrid personalities. His imagery, with regards to the set description and dialogue, gave the play a bizarre, inhuman feel. The ways in which he had his characters behaving and the images their dialogue inspired set up a disconnect between the readers and the characters that helped highlight their warped sense of morals. Through his use of these and other literary techniques in Dream, Albee gave additional support to the concepts around which he based his message.
         With these and other close reading observations, along with our in-class discussions, I was able to take more away from The American Dream than any other piece of literature I've read. Now as I'm annotating the piece, I'm finding myself able to draw some of my own conclusions thanks to the skills we've begun to develop as a class, and it's got me really excited for the rest of they year.

Sunday, September 22, 2013

Open Prompt Critique

(2008 Prompt, Question #3: "Function of a Foil")

Critique #1: This student answers both parts of the prompt, but provides a lackluster analysis of a foil relationship in The Joy Luck Club. Initially, she doesn't clearly identify what ideas she's going to address in her essay, and it's difficult to follow her train of thought because her thesis statement lacks specificity. She claims that Huang serves as a foil for Lindo, but she doesn't state the characteristics or qualities that are emphasized. Additionally, she says that the relationship between the two characters contributes to the meaning of the literary work, but she doesn't say how. Her first two body paragraphs are basically a summary of The Joy Luck Club that helps the reader become familiar with the relationship between Huang and Lindo, but doesn't explicitly identify how the former is a foil for the latter. She does do a good job of providing evidence for her second claim, however, as she explains how Huang's treatment of Lindo helped her find self-worth in spite of the degradation she was forced to endure. Her conclusion is effective in that it restates her thesis, but like her intro, it's a little too vague. I'd give this student a 5.

Critique #2: This student fails to clearly answer the prompt, beginning with a hastily thrown-together intro paragraph that lacks a defined thesis statement. Interestingly enough, the word "foil" is actually nowhere to be found until the conclusion paragraph, making the purpose of the essay a mystery to all readers. She clearly emphasizes the relationship between Celle and her father from The Color Purple in the first body paragraph, but never actually suggests that one character might be a foil for the other. Instead, she describes the abuse Celle was subjected to at the hands of her father, and the emotional effect it had on her. To deviate even further from the objective, this student's second body paragraph introduces another supporting character, Shug, and describes her relationship with Celle. The student uses comparisons between both Shug and Celle's father to analyze gender roles in the novel, but fails to identify a foil and provide an explanation of it's function in the narrative, as dictated by the prompt. The conclusion finally presents the idea that Celle's father serves a foil to her as she finds her identity, but at that point it's difficult for readers to connect the information in her body paragraphs with this new claim. I'd give this student a 3.

Critique #3: This student very obviously either misunderstood the prompt, or isn't familiar with the term "foil". His basic intro paragraph does contain a rather general thesis statement, but the main issue with the paper lies in his body paragraphs. Firstly, his writing style is rather immature, marked by short sentences and simplistic vocabulary, and indicates a limited ability to use the English language effectively to communicate his ideas, particularly when trying to describe the familial tie between Baba and Hassan of The Kite Runner. This comes through in his body paragraphs, in which he talks primarily about the way Baba and Hassan are similar, despite having just declared Baba a foil for Hassan. The one contrast he does identify, regarding the difference in wealth and popularity between the two characters, doesn't necessarily emphasize the good qualities of Hassan, as this student claimed in his thesis statement. Finally, the conclusion incorrectly addresses the second part of the prompt in a single sentence, highlighting certain qualities the two characters share that coincide with the major themes of the novel, instead of analyzing the function of a foil relationship. I'd give this student a 2.

Sunday, September 15, 2013

Critical Response Essay: In the End, New Yorkers Reject Bad Boy Candidates

http://ideas.time.com/2013/09/11/in-the-end-new-yorkers-reject-bad-boy-candidates/

Scandalous politicians have been on a roll in the city of New York this past year, and a flood of opinion pieces have been published in response. In this article, Time contributor Errol Louis uses rhetorical elements like diction, language, and details to comment on the absurdity of his hometown's political scene, while concurrently providing readers with an explanation.
      Firstly, Louis's use of colloquial diction makes his article accessible to the average reader, which is imperative in order for it's message to hit home. After all, the piece is ultimately about the diversity of our country's greatest city, and the tolerance that is required of its residents. A universal message like that demands a voice that the people of all walks of life can understand and relate to. He even uses the occasional slang term like "bad boy" to subtly make fun of the politicians under scrutiny, a bit of humor that can draw reader's attention and help them to connect with the meaning of the piece. Even so, he uses diction intelligently enough to communicate his credibility, particularly when providing readers with data from the polls, supporting his claims about New Yorkers' political response.
      Secondly, Louis uses language that highlights the important elements of his message. Words like "paradox"--as used in the first sentence--effectively express his claim that tolerance and acceptance are fundamentally different concepts, an idea that contrasts with our general knowledge of the words, but which further reading reveals to be true. In addition, his frequent use of the term "diversity" challenges our typical understanding of the word. Personally, I generally apply it to ethnic or racial differences, but here Louis uses it to describe the cultural and behavioral differences between people, a usage that is perhaps more appropriate in a country that ought to focus less on the geographical origins of its residents, and more on how they can contribute to their communities. Through language, we notice somewhat of a subtext in the article.
     Thirdly, Louis includes plenty of detail in order to emphasize the difference between people--and between politicians--that makes a level of tolerance so important to everyday life, particularly in a diverse metropolis like NYC. For example, Louis notes how "punk rockers live next door to opera fans" and he even recognizes how LGBTQ societies can occasionally find some common ground with religious groups. By highlighting the ways in which our behaviors differ, he more vividly illustrates his point to his readers.
     Through rhetoric, Errol Louis not only explained why New Yorkers have a tendency to entertain the brash behavior of some of its political icons, but he implied that such tolerance might not be a bad thing after all. In fact, Louis implies, it's probably a direction the entire country should head in--as long as we don't forget how to "quietly reject" the "bad boys"in the end.