This month, my classmates and I were introduced to a new exercise designed to expand our understanding of how writers use language to create mood and atmosphere. Our task was to choose a digital image from a wide variety, identify a word that describes it's mood perfectly, and then collectively write a description of the image without using said word. Then, we had to defend our creation of mood using specific DIDL examples from our description. It will presumably prove helpful as we prepare for the AP exam, and so far it's made for a great discussion stimulator. Trying to find a perfectly descriptive word for a visual image is no easy task, and our understanding of the power of diction has developed as a result. The fact that we were provided with a limited vocabulary from which to choose forced us to recognize and respond to the little nuances of language that can make all the difference when trying to create mood. We've done exercises similar to this in earlier language arts courses, but the added charge of defending our description turned this into a fresh learning experience. Having to go back and validate our work helped us to realize exactly what it was (syntactical elements, diction, imagery, etc.), that created the mood we were going for. I've been applying these skills to my reading of Hamlet in class, and The Hobbit at home. The exercise inspired me to pay closer attention to literary techniques that Shakespeare and Tolkien use to create their own atmospheres, and how they function within the piece in terms of its overall meaning.
In addition to that, the vast majority of our November class time has been devoted to completing our discussions of Death of a Salesman and reading Hamlet. My S&A blog post for Salesman already presents the products of our in-class discussion, so I'll refer all readers to it for that. However, I think the style of discussion we experimented with this month is definitely worth mentioning. Since the beginning of November, our formerly socratic discussions morphed into "Goldfish Bowl" discussions. This entailed that up to four students sat in the middle and shared their opinions and interpretations while the rest of the class silently listened. Other students could then enter the discussion by switching places with one of the original "goldfish". I found that this type of discussion helped us uncover meaning more quickly, because we were only able to share our ideas once we had thought them over carefully and found an opportune time to enter the bowl. This way, our class was able to avoid irrelevant chatter and dig deeply into the text. In American Literature two years ago, Mrs. Reed set up discussions for Great Gatsby in a similar way, but they were relatively ineffective because the level of interest in the material was lower in that classroom. By contrast, our AP Lit. class has no shortage of students eager to get involved in discussion, and I think we've greatly benefited from this new method. Outside of the classroom, I could see employers utilizing a similar method of discussion to engage committees or project teams and inspire greater productivity in their workplace.
Once we wrapped up Salesman, Hamlet loomed large as the next literary obstacle to be tackled by our class. Having just finished our preliminary reading, I can say that it's no surprise that many consider Shakespeare's tale of a deeply-conflicted Danish prince to be the greatest play of all time. It truly is an incredibly influential and deliciously complex piece of literature that is both overwhelming and exciting to me as a first-time reader with a somewhat limited background knowledge of Shakespeare's works. It certainly is less accessible than Romeo and Juliet, which we read freshman year, and I think analyzing it will prove to be quite challenging, especially since all of our reading so far has been in a more contemporary version of English. However, I can't wait to uncover more of Hamlet's range of influence as we delve into our discussion. Coming into the course, I had recently learned of the parallels many had drawn between the play and Disney's The Lion King. Thus, the Bard's infiltration of the family film genre was revealed to me. As I become better acquainted with the piece, it will be interesting to identify what other realms of popular culture its themes and archetypes appear in.
Sunday, November 24, 2013
Sunday, November 17, 2013
Open Prompt Critique (#3)
(2006 Prompt, Question #3: "Country Setting as a Source of Values")
Critique #1: This student crafts a complete essay that responds directly to the prompt in an insightful way. She begins well, acknowledging a counter-argument in her thesis statement, and then effectively presenting her own position in contrast. This technique provides a certain clarity to the reader that helps them identify exactly the direction in which the rest of the piece will go. She then carefully separates her claims about setting in Jane Austen's Persuasion into body paragraphs that retain their focus throughout. Her language isn't confusing or contradictory, either, give or take a few grammatical/spelling slip-ups. In addition, she's careful to conclude each body paragraph with a warranting sentence that ties her evidence back to her thesis. Looking at the grader's response, I was legitimately surprised at the students grade of an 8. Personally, I couldn't find any issues significant enough to justify the loss of a point. Perhaps the student could have been more direct in her conclusion. I suppose her focus waivers slightly in the final paragraph, and technically speaking, a more clear restatement of her thesis may have gotten her that last point. Personally, though, I liked the flow of her conclusion, and I think it served it's function of wrapping up her essay and re-hashing her argument. I'd give this student a 9.
Critique #2: This student is only partially effective in answering the entire prompt, and fails to present valuable evidence in a way that highlights it's connection to his thesis statement. In his introductory paragraph, the student establishes the country setting in The Importance of Being Ernest as one of "tranquility", but fails to provide evidence for this claim in any of his body paragraphs. Instead, he mainly focuses on the function of two settings (rural vs. urban) in the comedic process. His first body paragraph is all summary, and doesn't refer to the prompt or the thesis at all, while his only other body paragraph addresses a portion of his thesis, but fails to explain how the country setting serves as a source of values, as delineated in the prompt. The essay received an official score of 6, which I think could've have been raised if the student crafted a more complete thesis statement that made claims according to the prompt, instead of getting distracted by the role of the setting in creating comedy. I think This would have helped to keep the student on track to construct a tighter essay. As it is though, I'd give this student no more than a 5.
Critique #3: This student attempts answers the prompt with a unique position, but she provides little relevant evidence and her phrasing is nearly incomprehensible, squandering any potential her essay may have had. Firstly, the student fails to clearly identify a thesis statement that establishes her claims, and the introductory paragraph in general is very vague. The rest of the essay is devoted to explaining how Faulkner used the setting of the south, as morally "backwards" as it is, as a plot device to justify the actions of the bizarre actions of the characters in As I Lay Dying. While this claim, were it clearly identified, would be an effective answer to the prompt, the textual evidence included by the student fails to reinforce the rural setting as a source of values. Instead, she focuses on the strange behavior of the characters and provides inadequate warrants back to her essentially non-existent thesis statement. This student received a score of 4, which honestly seems a little generous. I think the student could have benefited from spending more time on the organization of her thoughts, as well as her construction of warrants. The root of the problem, however, seems to be her lack of a real thesis statement, which generally serves as the cornerstone of a writer's argument. I'd give this student a 3.
Critique #1: This student crafts a complete essay that responds directly to the prompt in an insightful way. She begins well, acknowledging a counter-argument in her thesis statement, and then effectively presenting her own position in contrast. This technique provides a certain clarity to the reader that helps them identify exactly the direction in which the rest of the piece will go. She then carefully separates her claims about setting in Jane Austen's Persuasion into body paragraphs that retain their focus throughout. Her language isn't confusing or contradictory, either, give or take a few grammatical/spelling slip-ups. In addition, she's careful to conclude each body paragraph with a warranting sentence that ties her evidence back to her thesis. Looking at the grader's response, I was legitimately surprised at the students grade of an 8. Personally, I couldn't find any issues significant enough to justify the loss of a point. Perhaps the student could have been more direct in her conclusion. I suppose her focus waivers slightly in the final paragraph, and technically speaking, a more clear restatement of her thesis may have gotten her that last point. Personally, though, I liked the flow of her conclusion, and I think it served it's function of wrapping up her essay and re-hashing her argument. I'd give this student a 9.
Critique #2: This student is only partially effective in answering the entire prompt, and fails to present valuable evidence in a way that highlights it's connection to his thesis statement. In his introductory paragraph, the student establishes the country setting in The Importance of Being Ernest as one of "tranquility", but fails to provide evidence for this claim in any of his body paragraphs. Instead, he mainly focuses on the function of two settings (rural vs. urban) in the comedic process. His first body paragraph is all summary, and doesn't refer to the prompt or the thesis at all, while his only other body paragraph addresses a portion of his thesis, but fails to explain how the country setting serves as a source of values, as delineated in the prompt. The essay received an official score of 6, which I think could've have been raised if the student crafted a more complete thesis statement that made claims according to the prompt, instead of getting distracted by the role of the setting in creating comedy. I think This would have helped to keep the student on track to construct a tighter essay. As it is though, I'd give this student no more than a 5.
Critique #3: This student attempts answers the prompt with a unique position, but she provides little relevant evidence and her phrasing is nearly incomprehensible, squandering any potential her essay may have had. Firstly, the student fails to clearly identify a thesis statement that establishes her claims, and the introductory paragraph in general is very vague. The rest of the essay is devoted to explaining how Faulkner used the setting of the south, as morally "backwards" as it is, as a plot device to justify the actions of the bizarre actions of the characters in As I Lay Dying. While this claim, were it clearly identified, would be an effective answer to the prompt, the textual evidence included by the student fails to reinforce the rural setting as a source of values. Instead, she focuses on the strange behavior of the characters and provides inadequate warrants back to her essentially non-existent thesis statement. This student received a score of 4, which honestly seems a little generous. I think the student could have benefited from spending more time on the organization of her thoughts, as well as her construction of warrants. The root of the problem, however, seems to be her lack of a real thesis statement, which generally serves as the cornerstone of a writer's argument. I'd give this student a 3.
Wednesday, November 13, 2013
Summary and Analysis: Death of a Salesman
As one of America's most influential dramatists, Arthur Miller's contributions to the western literary canon have been tremendous. Born in New York City in 1915, Miller discovered his aptitude for playwriting during his studies at the University of Michigan. Following his graduation in 1938, Miller went on to write what would become his first commercial success, the drama All My Sons. The play revealed Miller's obsession with the "American Dream", a concept that he would continue to explore in much of his later work. Following up on that success, Miller penned Death of a Salesman, the play that would come to define him for future generations. In his masterpiece, Miller comments on the eventual self-destruction that can result from valuing the power of words over actions in the pursuit of conventional success. He also suggests that a loss of dignity and a devastation of familial relationships are inevitable byproducts of such a lopsided philosophy. In the timeless character of misguided everyman Willy Loman, Miller pays tribute to a bygone version of the American Dream, while shining a harsh light on modern times.
The play opens with Willy Loman's return to his modest, single-family home in a neighborhood of Brooklyn, New York. The traditional American middle-class setting that surrounds the action of the play helps to emphasize the averageness of the Loman clan. As the narrative unfolds, this heightens a sense of sad irony, as Miller's woebegone protagonist yearns desperately for greatness. Before any dialogue is shared between character's, it's clear that Willy is a man running on empty. As a traveling salesman, he has lived his life by a special creed, a deeply rooted belief in the power of human relationships and the sense of trust that is such a vital part of them. As the years have gone by, Willy hasn't achieved the success he expected for himself based off of his constant determination to be "well-liked." In a conversation with his wife Linda regarding their mortgage payments early in the first act, Willy glumly states, "Figure it out. Work a lifetime to pay off a house. You finally own it, and there's nobody to live in it"(Miller 4). The line perfectly summarizes his disappointment with life, while connecting it to a sense of materialism that is so closely associated with the image of conventional success that he deeply desires. This mounting dissatisfaction has taken a toll on Willy--who's now in his sixties--and by the time the play begins, his dignity has taken a serious hit. As a result, his mind has begun to wander into the past, where is able to find temporary joy in memories of more hopeful times and search for the root of all of his sorrow. His wife, Linda Loman, struggles to protect what is left of his sense of self-respect while encouraging him to accept his life for what it is. The "loving" relationship between her and her husband has grown increasingly one-sided as Willy's image of his future achievements has failed to materialize. On top of that, their two sons, Biff and Happy, who Willy looked at as a sort of saving grace, haven't amounted to much since they left home. Miller's portrayal of a troubling family dynamic held together by tenuous relationships sends a powerful message regarding a man's ability to take care of his family in the face of crushing disappointment.
As the story progresses, we learn that Biff, Willy's favorite son, has returned home from a ranching job out west. We also learn that he's brought back with him a sense of bitterness towards his father that has severely weakened the bond they once had. Through a series of flashbacks, this former bond is revealed, along with the way in which Willy raised his sons. In an impossibly idyllic vision of a moment in the family's past, Willy boosts Biff's confidence before a champion football game that has the potential to turn him into a great success. It it is here that Willy's philosophical imbalance becomes apparent. He's all talk, boasting of his dubious business achievements and inflating the egos of his two sons, even at the expense of Biff's smaller, weaker and less-liked friend, Bernard. Bernard, a studious and responsible young man, serves as a foil to Biff, who has been spoiled by his father's pride and an assurance that "the man who creates personal interest, is the man who gets ahead"(Miller 21). This line encapsulates Willy's belief in style over substance, in words over actions. According to him, the man who can convince enough people of his greatness will be great. With this advice and a constant stream of praise, Willy sets his well-built progeny up for failure. Later in the play, we discover that Willy has passed down a propensity for lying to his sons, a detail that further emphasizes the unreliable nature of words as tools with which to achieve success.
In the second act, Willy grapples with his misguidance following a brutal encounter with reality. Encouraged by his wife and a sense of crippling weariness, Willy asks his young boss, Howard, for a different position stationed closer to home. He expects his wish to be granted based off of a couple of absent-minded promises and a friendly relationship he had with Howard's father, who owned the company up until his death. Howard initially blows off Willy's requests due to his fixation with a tape-recorder, and eventually fires him all together. Thusly, Willy comes to realize the minimal value that his reputation holds in the face of a modern American business world based around new principles that don't honor old promises or affinities. When Willy proclaims, "You can't eat the orange and throw the peel away---a man is not a piece of fruit!"(Miller 62), he is expressing his complete disbelief in this modern approach to business, and revealing a fundamental misunderstanding of the world that has led to his own failure and the dysfunction of his family.
Meanwhile, Biff's relationships with his mother and his brother are strained as he pits his own resentment towards his father against their undying love and admiration for him. As Willy returns on his mental voyage through the past, we finally discover the source of that resentment. In the realm of Willy's mind, we watch Biff--looking for his dad to bail him out of a failed class with some smooth-talking--walk in on Willy and a mysterious woman in a Boston hotel room. In that moment, Biff's world turns upside down. He breaks into sobs as he realizes that his idol betrayed him--by betraying his mother--and that he can no longer pursue the dreams that Willy had for him. By catching his father in such a serious lie, Biff's faith in him and all of his wisdom is permanently shaken. So much so, in fact, that he gives up on school and abandons his athletic scholarships, choosing instead to move west and adopt a lifestyle different in almost every way to the one that Willy had hoped for him to have. Back in the present, Willy returns home with a packet of seeds, a meager representation of the investment he made in his son, and a conflicted mindset. He consults with a memory of his brother Ben, a conventionally successful man that Willy admired greatly in life. Ben had made appearances in flashbacks throughout the play, deified in Willy's memory, providing enigmatic answers to Willy's constant question's regarding the key to success. The brothers talk business regarding the idea of committing suicide in order to claim a twenty-thousand dollar life insurance policy. Willy sees it as his only opportunity to provide Biff with something to make up for destroying his faith. He recognizes it as a last hope for success, because with "twenty thousand behind him" he still believes Biff can be "magnificent". In a way, the seeds Willy brought home represent a resilient feeling of hope amidst all the despair of his own failure.
Shortly thereafter, Biff confronts Willy, explaining to his decaying father that he's leaving New York. What starts as a calm parting of ways becomes a furious ideological exchange in which Biff cries, "Pop! I'm a dime a dozen, and so are you!"(Miller 105). This exhausted exclamation represents Biff's total rejection of his father's belief system, and his emotional need to separate himself from the man and the ideas that have hindered his own self-discovery. The verbal sparring match ends in tears and reconciliation, as Biff proclaims his identity through sobs at his father's feet, Willy takes this display of emotion as much-needed assurance of his son's love for him. As everyone goes to bed, the narrative ends with Willy, inspired by his brother Ben's words and convinced he is doing the right thing for Biff and the rest of the family, killing himself in the name of greatness.
All the meaning that can be derived from the plot and characters is given greater complexity and depth with Miller's use of literary techniques. For example, Willy's frequent use of elevated diction, combined with his socio-economic status and his education level, gave him an air of falsity, and emphasized the motif of "words over action" that is so frequently associated with his character. Additionally, objects like the tape-recorder in Howard's office and the packet of seeds are heavily symbolic. Miller uses dialogue and stage instructions to create tonal shifts when necessary throughout the play.
Sunday, November 10, 2013
Critical Response Essay: Is It O.K. to Kill Cyclists?
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/10/opinion/sunday/is-it-ok-to-kill-cyclists.html?_r=0&adxnnl=1&ref=opinion&pagewanted=2&adxnnlx=1384109837-Cl0T5PBWM6z0/EMgDinWxg
In recent years, bicycling
has grown in popularity as a mode of transportation and a form of exercise. However, American drivers have struggled to safely and respectfully share
the roads with commuters and fitness enthusiasts who prefer bicycles, which
lack the degree of physical protection offered by larger vehicles. Injury and
death has frequently resulted from poor cooperation between these two rival
demographics, and those behind the wheel rarely face serious legal
consequences. In his opinion piece written for The New York Times, titled:
"Is It O.K. to Kill Cyclists?", Daniel Duane uses rhetorical
techniques like diction, imagery and detail to communicate the absurdity of this injustice
faced by cyclists.
Throughout the piece, Duane utilizes a blend of colloquial
and formal diction to establish his credibility while avoiding an air of
pretension, and to effectively express his position in a way that is accessible
to a wide range of readers. Words like "meagerness" and "negligence" color the piece with linguistic variety, while slang terms like
"hipster" and "fixie" give the piece cultural relevance
that a larger audience can identify with. More specifically, however, he uses
careful word choice to express his disbelief over a questionable pattern of
legal behavior. For example, Duane aptly states, "there is something undeniably screwy about a justice system that makes
it de facto legal to kill people." His use of the word "screwy" conveys a
sense of illogic, that not only makes this flaw in our justice system seem
wrong, but downright preposterous.
Duane also employs imagery as an intriguing opener for his appeal to our common sense. Recounting a particularly perilous bike ride, he writes "I watched an SUV driver hit another cyclist, and then I got my own front wheel caught in a streetcar track, sending me to the pavement." This image of misfortune draws readers in by providing an exaggerated example of the dangers faced by cyclists. Considering the controversial and emotionally-charged nature of this issue,
using language to illustrate tragic loss and the injustice that
inevitably follows is also a particularly effective tool for building a strong
position. For example, Duane creates a disturbing image by writing "If
your 13-year-old daughter bikes to school tomorrow inside a freshly painted
bike lane, and a driver runs a stop sign and kills her and then says to the
cop, 'Gee, I so totally did not mean to do that,' that will most likely be good
enough." By placing an image of innocence into the minds of his readers in
the form of a young girl, Duane opens us up to emotional response.
Subsequently, he is able to effectively elicit that sort of response by
subjecting that image to the sort of injustice that many cyclists who are
probably equally innocent--but less cute--unfortunately experience.
Additionally, Duane provides scads of detail to help strengthen his position. He includes an interesting quote from "bike law" attorney Ray Thomas that shines some light on the legal process surrounding a car/bike accident. According to Thomas "'jurors identify with drivers...they just think, well, I could make the same mistake. So they don't convict.'" This sort of relevant detail helps to validate Duane's argument by bringing up the jury's role in the issue. Because of the mandatory involvement of American citizens in jury duty, readers can relate to this information, and therefore become more actively engaged in his argument. On top of that, Duane included a real-life example of prejudice towards cyclists in their struggle for their share of the road. His anecdote about Sgt. Ernst and Ms. Le Moullac revealed a degree of indifference by the police toward the plight of wounded cyclists. Duane's incorporation of a specific instance in which proper consequences weren't appropriated to a guilty driver helps express the reality of a problem that touches everyone, whether you're behind the wheel or the handlebars.
Through his use of diction, imagery and detail, among other rhetorical techniques, Daniel Duane is able to spread awareness of a serious injustice, the repercussions of which are being felt by more and more as many Americans begin to adopt a new, two-wheeled lifestyle.
Additionally, Duane provides scads of detail to help strengthen his position. He includes an interesting quote from "bike law" attorney Ray Thomas that shines some light on the legal process surrounding a car/bike accident. According to Thomas "'jurors identify with drivers...they just think, well, I could make the same mistake. So they don't convict.'" This sort of relevant detail helps to validate Duane's argument by bringing up the jury's role in the issue. Because of the mandatory involvement of American citizens in jury duty, readers can relate to this information, and therefore become more actively engaged in his argument. On top of that, Duane included a real-life example of prejudice towards cyclists in their struggle for their share of the road. His anecdote about Sgt. Ernst and Ms. Le Moullac revealed a degree of indifference by the police toward the plight of wounded cyclists. Duane's incorporation of a specific instance in which proper consequences weren't appropriated to a guilty driver helps express the reality of a problem that touches everyone, whether you're behind the wheel or the handlebars.
Through his use of diction, imagery and detail, among other rhetorical techniques, Daniel Duane is able to spread awareness of a serious injustice, the repercussions of which are being felt by more and more as many Americans begin to adopt a new, two-wheeled lifestyle.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)