(2008 Prompt, Question #3: "Function of a Foil")
In Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman, the minor character Bernard serves as a foil to main character Biff Loman. Throughout the play, the audience learns of Bernard's physical weakness, his high intellect, and his social unpopularity, all of which are traits that highlight distinctly opposite features in Biff. As the narrative unfolds and Biff repeatedly fails in establishing a career and adopting a conventional lifestyle, Bernard's overwhelming success as lawyer and a father does much to emphasize the misguidance Biff experienced at the hands of his father. Through this contrast, Miller laments the struggle of the middle-class to achieve an unattainable version of success through the preservation of outdated values.
Early in the play, the protagonist, Willy Loman, experiences a vision of the past in which his son Biff is preparing for a championship football game as the starting quarterback. As the excitement of the day is reaching it's peak, the neighbor boy Bernard--a friend of Biff's from school-- rushes in to chastise Biff for avoiding his studies. He is met with ridicule from both Willy and his son. Here, readers are given a clear indication of how Willy has raised Biff. Biff doesn't feel that his academics are a priority due to his talent on the field and in the social realm, as his father has encouraged him that being "well-liked" is the key to real success. Through Bernard's embarrassment and frustration in this scene, Miller reveals important information about the man Biff has become in the shadow of his father's values and beliefs.
It's not just Bernard's geeky attitude towards school that paints a target on his back in the eyes of Lomans. As Biff and his brother Happy push him around while they taunt his studious behavior, another aspect of their foil relationship is made clear. Next to the handsome and athletic build of Biff, Bernard's physical weakness is in stark contrast. Once again, however, his notable inferiority to Biff in this way functions mainly to showcase Biff's misunderstanding of his own abilities and the challenges of the evolving society in which he is growing up. While Biff looks like a picture of youthful bravado next to an "anemic" like Bernard, his utter failure to achieve conventional success later on perfectly illustrates the ways in which he was ill-prepared for the harsh conditions of modern American society.
In the same scene, Willy seizes an opportunity to make an example of Bernard's numerous "shortcomings" in order teach his sons about what really matters: popularity. After they've shooed him away, Willy questions Bernard's ability to thrive in the social circles of high school, and Biff follows up with an earlier line of Willy's in reference to Bernard, who is "liked, but not well-liked". Willy goes on to praise Biff's ability to win the friendship of his classmates, particularly the girls, which sets up another distinct contrast between Biff and Bernard, perhaps the most important one. Bernard's social deficiency functions as a foil to Biff's ladies man persona, and speaks volumes about the society in which they live. 15 years later, it's brainy Bernard whose achieved the American Dream, while Biff becomes cynical and frustrated, despite his once desirable charm.
Bernard's considerably different set of values, as exposed in this scene, create a sense of tragic irony. As he goes to achieve the very conventional success that, in Willy's mind, was rightfully Biff's, the arrogance that the Loman's once felt turns into a sort of sad confusion. With this, Miller illustrates the misfortune bound to befall a middle-class unwilling to adapt to the changing societal values of a post-war America.
Sunday, April 20, 2014
Wednesday, April 16, 2014
Summary and Analysis: Ceremony
Ceremony
Author:
Native American author Leslie Marmon Silko published Ceremony--her first novel--in 1977. Her breadth of work is often associated with the literary movement known as the Native American Renaissance. Some of her other works include Storyteller, Delicacy and Strength of Lace, and Almanac of the Dead.
Setting:
The Laguna Pueblo reservation in west-central New Mexico and the surrounding areas.
Characters:
Tayo--
A Laguna Pueblo man of mixed ethnicity. As a child he was taken to live with his Aunt and her family after his mother proved unfit to care for him. Growing up, he showed a deep appreciation for Laguna spiritual culture despite an obvious distance between himself and the rest of his community. He enlisted in the U.S. army to serve in World War II alongside his cousin Rocky. After Rocky was killed during the Bataan Death March, Tayo returned to the Laguna Pueblo reservation spiritually devastated. However, he holds within him the power to restore the natural balance of Laguna people weakened by war.
A Laguna Pueblo man of mixed ethnicity. As a child he was taken to live with his Aunt and her family after his mother proved unfit to care for him. Growing up, he showed a deep appreciation for Laguna spiritual culture despite an obvious distance between himself and the rest of his community. He enlisted in the U.S. army to serve in World War II alongside his cousin Rocky. After Rocky was killed during the Bataan Death March, Tayo returned to the Laguna Pueblo reservation spiritually devastated. However, he holds within him the power to restore the natural balance of Laguna people weakened by war.
Betonie--
A Laguna Pueblo medicine man. Betonie is part Mexican, and therefore shares a special bond with Tayo. He rejects some Laguna cultural traditions commonly accepted by healers, such as living on the reservation. Instead, he resides on the edge of a desert town populated mostly by social outcasts and the impoverished. Along with his quirks, Betonie possesses a great wisdom, and a deep understanding of the natural and spiritual worlds around him. This knowledge is instrumental in guiding Tayo on his journey to restore harmony for the Laguna people.
Uncle Josiah--
Josiah is Tayo's uncle and Auntie's sister. Upon Auntie's adoption of Tayo, he became a father figure to him, teaching him, alongside--Old Grandmother--valuable lessons about the land and stories make up the foundation of the Laguna heritage. Josiah is distinguished by his great impulses and the decisions that result from them (i.e. the purchase of the Mexican cattle, his dubious relationship with Night Swan). Despite this, his vital role in Tayo's development and the love he received in return clearly mark him as a force for good, further emphasized by Tayo's deep spiritual disturbance resulting from his death while Tayo is at war in Japan.
Rocky--
Rocky is Tayo's cousin, and despite some significant personality and attitude differences between the two, he was also Tayo's closest childhood friend, right up until he was killed in action during the pair's tour of duty in World War II. Growing up, Rocky showed disinterest and a little contempt for his Laguna heritage, choosing instead to pursue sports and academics in an attempt to achieve the sort of conventional "white" success that his mother coveted so deeply. His death was the primary contributor to Tayo's spiritual sickness. Rocky serves as a foil to Tayo, highlighting that qualities possessed by Tayo that are held in high esteem within Laguna culture.
Old Grandma--
Tayo's grandmother. She is a fervent believer in Laguna spiritual practices and clings deeply to her heritage and the culture of her people. She always favored Tayo over Rocky and encouraged him in his search for spiritual healing following his return from the war. She was the one who initially summoned Ku'oosh.
Auntie--
Tayo's aunt. She took Tayo in when her sister Laura could longer adequately provide for him. This is a constant source of shame and torment for her as she faces the judgement of the other Laguna on the reservation. Ironically, she is a practicing Catholic and rejects many aspects of Laguna culture. She held great pride in her son Rocky, who she hoped would one day leave the reservation and find success in the "white" world, which through some twisted logic she felt would balance out the failure and disgrace of her sister and the son she bore.
Emo--
A fellow Laguna Pueblo man and war veteran to Tayo. Emo is short for Geronimo, the name of a ruthless apache warlord. Following his return from the war, Emo and his group of cronies spent most of their time in the local bars, getting drunk and reminiscing about the acceptance they felt as U.S. soldiers and the wonders of white culture. In doing so, Emo engaged in self-oppression and perpetuated a feeling of inferiority in his friends and consequently the entire Laguna community. Emo's immoral stories and lust for violence establish him as the main antagonist of the novel, a source of evil who stands in the way of spiritual harmony and recovery as brought about by Tayo through his healing ceremonies.
Plot Summary:
As young boy of mixed Laguna Pueblo and Mexican ethnicity, Tayo is brought to live with his aunt and grandmother after his impoverished mother can no longer provide for him. There, he connects with his Laguna heritage while observing a distance between himself and his Christian aunt, who is deeply ashamed of his sister. He also grows close with his Uncle Josiah and his cousin Rocky, who wants little to do with Laguna culture. When the two are older, they enlist to fight in the U.S. Army during World War II. Upon their deployment, they are shipped to the Philippines and witness the horrific Bataan Death March, in which Rocky is killed. Tayo returns home from his tour of duty experiencing a deep spiritual disturbance that causes his physical health to deteriorate through violent bursts of sickness. After floundering for some time at home, still grieving the losses of both Rocky and his uncle and getting into a serious fight with a fellow veteran named Emo, his grandmother--who is a fervent believer in Laguna spiritual practices--summons a medicine man named Ku'oosh to assess Tayo's condition and do his best to heal him. Ku'oosh methods are not entirely effective, so he sends Tayo to a another medicine man named Betonie, who lives off of the reservation. Betonie explains that Tayo's sickness is due to dark witchery, and a growing evil that plagues all Laguna people. He tells Tayo that he is part of something bigger than himself, and that his own ability to find natural balance will ultimately determine the fate of his people. Betonie performs a number of brief, customary rituals and then instructs Tayo that he must find a herd of speckled Mexican cattle lost by his Uncle Josiah many years ago. His hunt leads him to the home of a mysterious woman named Ts'eh, with whom he spends the night and receives directions from in the morning. Tayo finds the cattle up corralled in a mountain pasture. He breaks into the pasture and is shortly arrested by a duo of white security guards. However, the arrival of a mountain lion distracts the guards and gives Tayo an opportunity to escape in the midst of a freak snow shower. Tayo returns to Ts'eh's house to find that she has the cattle. Tayo returns the cattle to the family's ranch, where he spends the summer with Ts'eh. Tayo soon learns that Emo and his gang of veterans are out to get him, and that they may be collaborating with the authorities in order to get him arrested. Tayo gets advice from Ts'eh on where to hide, and ends up in an abandoned uranium mine, a symbol of the subversion of Laguna culture at the hands of white people. He spends the night there, barely resisting the urge to kill Emo after he shows up and Tayo is forced to watch him brutally murder Harley. The next day, Tayo reaches out to Ku'oosh, who proclaims that the Tayo's ceremony had received the blessings of the spirit Corn Mother who was manifested in Ts'eh, and was successful in restoring the natural balance of good and evil to their world and saving the Laguna people.
Narrative Voice:
The novel is narrated in the third-person, and focuses on the perspective of the protagonist, Tayo. However, certain sections of the novel are written from the separate perspective of a different character, such as the beginning poetry sequence.
Author's Style:
Point of View--
Silko takes a positive position on human nature in Ceremony, using different spiritual facets of a downtrodden minority culture to exemplify the strength of human goodness against a greater force of inhuman evil.
Tone--
The tone of the novel is largely dark and sorrowful, but a distinct shift occurs following the climax that invigorates the narrative with a sense of hope that rises through the gloom of the Laguna's dire situation.
Theme:
In Ceremony, Silko suggests that in order to achieve a sense of personal and communal balance, one must understand that good and evil exist in everything and are therefore inappropriate classifications.
A Laguna Pueblo medicine man. Betonie is part Mexican, and therefore shares a special bond with Tayo. He rejects some Laguna cultural traditions commonly accepted by healers, such as living on the reservation. Instead, he resides on the edge of a desert town populated mostly by social outcasts and the impoverished. Along with his quirks, Betonie possesses a great wisdom, and a deep understanding of the natural and spiritual worlds around him. This knowledge is instrumental in guiding Tayo on his journey to restore harmony for the Laguna people.
Uncle Josiah--
Josiah is Tayo's uncle and Auntie's sister. Upon Auntie's adoption of Tayo, he became a father figure to him, teaching him, alongside--Old Grandmother--valuable lessons about the land and stories make up the foundation of the Laguna heritage. Josiah is distinguished by his great impulses and the decisions that result from them (i.e. the purchase of the Mexican cattle, his dubious relationship with Night Swan). Despite this, his vital role in Tayo's development and the love he received in return clearly mark him as a force for good, further emphasized by Tayo's deep spiritual disturbance resulting from his death while Tayo is at war in Japan.
Rocky--
Rocky is Tayo's cousin, and despite some significant personality and attitude differences between the two, he was also Tayo's closest childhood friend, right up until he was killed in action during the pair's tour of duty in World War II. Growing up, Rocky showed disinterest and a little contempt for his Laguna heritage, choosing instead to pursue sports and academics in an attempt to achieve the sort of conventional "white" success that his mother coveted so deeply. His death was the primary contributor to Tayo's spiritual sickness. Rocky serves as a foil to Tayo, highlighting that qualities possessed by Tayo that are held in high esteem within Laguna culture.
Old Grandma--
Tayo's grandmother. She is a fervent believer in Laguna spiritual practices and clings deeply to her heritage and the culture of her people. She always favored Tayo over Rocky and encouraged him in his search for spiritual healing following his return from the war. She was the one who initially summoned Ku'oosh.
Auntie--
Tayo's aunt. She took Tayo in when her sister Laura could longer adequately provide for him. This is a constant source of shame and torment for her as she faces the judgement of the other Laguna on the reservation. Ironically, she is a practicing Catholic and rejects many aspects of Laguna culture. She held great pride in her son Rocky, who she hoped would one day leave the reservation and find success in the "white" world, which through some twisted logic she felt would balance out the failure and disgrace of her sister and the son she bore.
Emo--
A fellow Laguna Pueblo man and war veteran to Tayo. Emo is short for Geronimo, the name of a ruthless apache warlord. Following his return from the war, Emo and his group of cronies spent most of their time in the local bars, getting drunk and reminiscing about the acceptance they felt as U.S. soldiers and the wonders of white culture. In doing so, Emo engaged in self-oppression and perpetuated a feeling of inferiority in his friends and consequently the entire Laguna community. Emo's immoral stories and lust for violence establish him as the main antagonist of the novel, a source of evil who stands in the way of spiritual harmony and recovery as brought about by Tayo through his healing ceremonies.
Plot Summary:
As young boy of mixed Laguna Pueblo and Mexican ethnicity, Tayo is brought to live with his aunt and grandmother after his impoverished mother can no longer provide for him. There, he connects with his Laguna heritage while observing a distance between himself and his Christian aunt, who is deeply ashamed of his sister. He also grows close with his Uncle Josiah and his cousin Rocky, who wants little to do with Laguna culture. When the two are older, they enlist to fight in the U.S. Army during World War II. Upon their deployment, they are shipped to the Philippines and witness the horrific Bataan Death March, in which Rocky is killed. Tayo returns home from his tour of duty experiencing a deep spiritual disturbance that causes his physical health to deteriorate through violent bursts of sickness. After floundering for some time at home, still grieving the losses of both Rocky and his uncle and getting into a serious fight with a fellow veteran named Emo, his grandmother--who is a fervent believer in Laguna spiritual practices--summons a medicine man named Ku'oosh to assess Tayo's condition and do his best to heal him. Ku'oosh methods are not entirely effective, so he sends Tayo to a another medicine man named Betonie, who lives off of the reservation. Betonie explains that Tayo's sickness is due to dark witchery, and a growing evil that plagues all Laguna people. He tells Tayo that he is part of something bigger than himself, and that his own ability to find natural balance will ultimately determine the fate of his people. Betonie performs a number of brief, customary rituals and then instructs Tayo that he must find a herd of speckled Mexican cattle lost by his Uncle Josiah many years ago. His hunt leads him to the home of a mysterious woman named Ts'eh, with whom he spends the night and receives directions from in the morning. Tayo finds the cattle up corralled in a mountain pasture. He breaks into the pasture and is shortly arrested by a duo of white security guards. However, the arrival of a mountain lion distracts the guards and gives Tayo an opportunity to escape in the midst of a freak snow shower. Tayo returns to Ts'eh's house to find that she has the cattle. Tayo returns the cattle to the family's ranch, where he spends the summer with Ts'eh. Tayo soon learns that Emo and his gang of veterans are out to get him, and that they may be collaborating with the authorities in order to get him arrested. Tayo gets advice from Ts'eh on where to hide, and ends up in an abandoned uranium mine, a symbol of the subversion of Laguna culture at the hands of white people. He spends the night there, barely resisting the urge to kill Emo after he shows up and Tayo is forced to watch him brutally murder Harley. The next day, Tayo reaches out to Ku'oosh, who proclaims that the Tayo's ceremony had received the blessings of the spirit Corn Mother who was manifested in Ts'eh, and was successful in restoring the natural balance of good and evil to their world and saving the Laguna people.
Narrative Voice:
The novel is narrated in the third-person, and focuses on the perspective of the protagonist, Tayo. However, certain sections of the novel are written from the separate perspective of a different character, such as the beginning poetry sequence.
Author's Style:
Point of View--
Silko takes a positive position on human nature in Ceremony, using different spiritual facets of a downtrodden minority culture to exemplify the strength of human goodness against a greater force of inhuman evil.
Tone--
The tone of the novel is largely dark and sorrowful, but a distinct shift occurs following the climax that invigorates the narrative with a sense of hope that rises through the gloom of the Laguna's dire situation.
Theme:
In Ceremony, Silko suggests that in order to achieve a sense of personal and communal balance, one must understand that good and evil exist in everything and are therefore inappropriate classifications.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)