Critique #1: This student answers both parts of the prompt, but provides a lackluster analysis of a foil relationship in The Joy Luck Club. Initially, she doesn't clearly identify what ideas she's going to address in her essay, and it's difficult to follow her train of thought because her thesis statement lacks specificity. She claims that Huang serves as a foil for Lindo, but she doesn't state the characteristics or qualities that are emphasized. Additionally, she says that the relationship between the two characters contributes to the meaning of the literary work, but she doesn't say how. Her first two body paragraphs are basically a summary of The Joy Luck Club that helps the reader become familiar with the relationship between Huang and Lindo, but doesn't explicitly identify how the former is a foil for the latter. She does do a good job of providing evidence for her second claim, however, as she explains how Huang's treatment of Lindo helped her find self-worth in spite of the degradation she was forced to endure. Her conclusion is effective in that it restates her thesis, but like her intro, it's a little too vague. I'd give this student a 5.
Critique #2: This student fails to clearly answer the prompt, beginning with a hastily thrown-together intro paragraph that lacks a defined thesis statement. Interestingly enough, the word "foil" is actually nowhere to be found until the conclusion paragraph, making the purpose of the essay a mystery to all readers. She clearly emphasizes the relationship between Celle and her father from The Color Purple in the first body paragraph, but never actually suggests that one character might be a foil for the other. Instead, she describes the abuse Celle was subjected to at the hands of her father, and the emotional effect it had on her. To deviate even further from the objective, this student's second body paragraph introduces another supporting character, Shug, and describes her relationship with Celle. The student uses comparisons between both Shug and Celle's father to analyze gender roles in the novel, but fails to identify a foil and provide an explanation of it's function in the narrative, as dictated by the prompt. The conclusion finally presents the idea that Celle's father serves a foil to her as she finds her identity, but at that point it's difficult for readers to connect the information in her body paragraphs with this new claim. I'd give this student a 3.
Critique #3: This student very obviously either misunderstood the prompt, or isn't familiar with the term "foil". His basic intro paragraph does contain a rather general thesis statement, but the main issue with the paper lies in his body paragraphs. Firstly, his writing style is rather immature, marked by short sentences and simplistic vocabulary, and indicates a limited ability to use the English language effectively to communicate his ideas, particularly when trying to describe the familial tie between Baba and Hassan of The Kite Runner. This comes through in his body paragraphs, in which he talks primarily about the way Baba and Hassan are similar, despite having just declared Baba a foil for Hassan. The one contrast he does identify, regarding the difference in wealth and popularity between the two characters, doesn't necessarily emphasize the good qualities of Hassan, as this student claimed in his thesis statement. Finally, the conclusion incorrectly addresses the second part of the prompt in a single sentence, highlighting certain qualities the two characters share that coincide with the major themes of the novel, instead of analyzing the function of a foil relationship. I'd give this student a 2.