On top of all this Stoppardian goodness, we also found--or rather, made--time for a little open prompt practice. After all, we do have our big exam coming up in less than three months, which is horrifying when I think about it. I found our in-class speed response exercise to be be sort of ineffective. Honestly, it seemed as though we were trying to run before we could walk. At this point, I still have to take the time to methodically formulate an intro paragraph that outlines my response to all facets of the prompt, and I personally don't feel that I've reached the level of aptitude where I'm able to tackle that sort of an assignment within such a narrow timeframe (especially with the shortened hours). Believe you me, I understand the necessity of being able to write quickly for these AP exams, but in order to get high marks, I imagine I've got to lock down the quality of content before working on my efficiency. Hopefully we'll do more work with this soon, but not until after we get to the bottom of RGAD!
Sunday, February 16, 2014
Response to Course Material: February
This February has been filled with revelations. Some were exciting--others more disconcerting. After all, we started a brand new piece of literature this month. The brilliantly vexing Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead by Tom Stoppard. The play was really quite hilarious, which turned out to be a nice contrast from the gut-wrenching tragedy of Hamlet. That's not to say however, that RGAD was merely a tasty little morsel of intellectual comedy. Contrary to what Ian Johnston suggested in his lecture on Stoppard's breakout work, I was hit with an intense impression of meaning following our first reading of the play. As a class, we recognized some of the Absurdist elements we encountered in The American Dream, but as with Albee's play, we found some serious thematic material lurking just beneath the surface of all that snappy dialogue. Deciphering what we found was (and still is) the tricky part. To help us draw some conclusions, we watched a film adaptation of the play directed by Stoppard himself, which provided us with a valid interpretation of the work that we could cross-reference with the stage play itself. For me, the new medium added a whole new dimension to the piece, as Stoppard was able to control the action between the lines and thus elaborate on certain ideas and place greater emphasis on motifs of his choosing. For example, Rosencrantz's numerous, ground-breaking inventions that were so casually dismissed by Guildenstern were fascinating additions to the action. They helped to characterize Rosencrantz and complement Stoppard's ideas about choices, direction, and letting someone else "take the helm". Speaking of which, I found the boat metaphor to be a particularly interesting way to present the existentialist philosophy. To enhance my reading experience, I leafed through a copy of Nietzsche's essential writings I picked up used from Schuler's (six bucks--a real steal) and was able to make some enriching connections between Stoppard's insinuations through RGAD and the teachings of the founder of modern existentialism. Nietzsche's "God Is Dead" philosophy, as we may have mentioned in class, fits neatly with the action of RGAD. By placing such a heavy emphasis on the separation of art and reality, and concurrently the god-like power of the author, Stoppard suggests that us real human beings DO have the ability to exercise our free will and thus change the course of events in our lives. We are not characters bound by the written word, and thus we are burdened with free will and the consequences of our choices and decisions. Comparing Nietzsche's writings to the play was vital in my understanding of that theme.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Eddie,
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed your Nietzschean connection to Stoppard; Logan once tried to get me to read "The Birth of Tragedy", which was referenced earlier this year during the days of "Hamlet", but alas, nothing came of it. Even though we are done with R&G in class, I don't want to simply move on and forget the work; and if Nietzsche's works helped you in your understanding of the play I would certainly want to explore them more to help my own understanding. His writing possesses some of the same hallmark's as Stoppard, such as fitting large, abstract meanings into simple phrases and aphorisms that can take days of brain-wracking to comprehend, though the two are obviously not on the same level as writers. Anyway, your qualms with AP writing are quite valid, and they are very similar to mine. I've always been somewhat of a perfectionist when I'm writing, even when I'm doing a rough draft, and trying to get the words and phrasing just right during an AP essay has often caused me to run out of time, as well as causing me to obscure my meaning. This seems to happen every year with APs; I started off like this in APUSH and WHAP as well, but as time went on, I got up to a good solid median because I learned a formula. Unfortunately, the formula for AP Lit essays is a lot more malleable, and I think that's contributing to the problem. But, in all things that need mastering, practice is essential, so I'm sure that as time goes on we'll get up to that level.
Hi Eddie,
ReplyDeleteI have to be honest, but physically going to Schulers, buying a copy of Nietzsche's essential writings and reading it is probably a step above what most of us in AP Lit would do. However, you went even further and was able to use that information to help you understanding the relationship between Hamlet and RGAD and that really shows me (just like this post) the level of passion that you have for this class and literature itself. I really commend you for that. Ok so on to your post. I remember being paired with you a few other times and I think you really improved your "Response to Course material" posts. You did a nice job of refraining from simply summarizing the events in the class. Personally, I think a person can never have enough connections between life outside the classroom and the work we do in class, so I would have liked to see more of that kind of connection in your blog. On a different note, I had to do a double-take/read when you wrote about Stoppard's message to the readers because that was the exact same idea I went for in my Summary and Analysis! I thought I was weird for making a separate statement from the class, but I'm so glad that someone else out there thinks that Stoppard wants us to take control of our own lives because we do have that choice. Also, I'm on the same page as you in regards to the difficult task of writing an AP Essay with such limited time. Time was, and has always been my enemy. But after Holmes spent more time to let us get used to the format, I feel like I'm a bit more prepared, but not totally. Do you feel that the extra time we've spend in class to go over these essays has helped? I wish you and everyone else in AP Lit luck. Under the guidance of Holmes, I'm sure we'll have a good handle on this by May!
Hi Eddie!
ReplyDeleteIt seems like you were way ahead of everyone with your thoughts on the meaning of this book -- it took a lot of discussion for our class to get to what you wrote about the separation of art and reality. Do you think reading the Nietzsche helped you get there faster? I think it's really cool that you were that interested in his work enough to actually go read some of it.
I also had a really hard time with the thesis practice. Due to my inability to read directions, I spent nearly half the time trying to write a really good prompt, and actually didn't even start responding to one until almost the end of the hour. I can't write a thesis statement nearly as fast as I apparently should be able to. Like Drew, I get too focused on phrasing everything just right and end up not finishing my essay. You'd think I would learn from my mistakes but evidently not. Hopefully we'll feel more prepared by the time the test rolls around.
Nice work!