Sunday, February 9, 2014

Open Prompt Response #1

(2006 Prompt, Question #3: "Country Setting as a Source of Values")

      In Mark Twain's The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, the country setting plays a significant role in the narrative. Although American literature often emphasizes the peaceful, virtuous qualities of the countryside, Twain portrays the Deep South as a place of primitivism and ignorance, mired in prejudice. We're given at taste of this right at the beginning of the novel in the form of Huck's own father, a terribly bigoted drunk who lives on the muddies banks of the Mississippi. Later, as Huck embarks on his journey with his friend Jim, an escaped slave, this becomes particularly evident in their interactions with the feuding Grangerford and Shepherdson clans, as well as the troubled Wilks family. Through these characters, Twain makes a powerful statement about the backwards nature of their environment, and the social progress had to be made in America during the mid 1800's.
      Twain wastes little time in emphasizing the importance of Huck's surroundings to the narrative, which essentially begins with his abduction by his vagrant father, known less-than-affectionately as Pap. Pap symbolizes the socio-economic problems that plagued the American South during the Antebellum period, as he's basically a racist, misogynistic hobo who lives in a rural locale and subsists off the paltry wages he can get from temporal work. It's also significant that he's one of the first characters introduced into the action of novel, preceded only by Widow Douglas and her sister Ms. Watson, the two wealthy southern moralists and foster care-takers to Huck who differ in every way from Pap, yet still harbor his skewed views and prejudice. Through this contrast, Twain illustrates a country setting in which no one sits above the ignorance and primitivism that characterizes it.
      Further on in the narrative, as Huck and Jim traverse the might Mississippi River aboard their iconic raft, they encounter another prime example of the outdated social norms that Twain showcases in order to establish the backwards nature of his novel's setting. After the duo gets separated when their raft is demolished by a River boat, Huck comes across the Grangerford clan, a family who's hospitality towards Huck only briefly masks a history of violence and hostility. Huck learns of the family's long-standing feud with the Shepherdson's, a nearby family who's ancestor got tangled up in an argument with the Grangerfords that ended in blood. As Huck becomes swept up into their deadly grudge match, and sees almost all of them go down in a hail of bullets, we as readers are meant to recognize the horrifying social standards that must govern a place in which such a tragedy can unfold uninterrupted. Clearly, these two warring "clans" were operating on customs of a simpler, more ignorant time. By including their demise into the narrative, Twain is making a powerful statement about his character's surroundings.
      Interpreting Huck's environment as a microcosm for the the American South as a whole opens up an  interesting and necessary understanding of Twain's perspective on the social issues of his time and homeland. Huckleberry Finn depicts the dark side of Antebellum America, and Twain emphasizes the ignorance and violence through which the institution of slavery, among other lingering social issues, were allowed to thrive.
   

4 comments:

  1. Please complete this essay, Eddie. Yes, it's better to post a full intro (to show that you've genuinely started the assignment) than it is to do a blank post (with the hope of filling in something later, hoping to just make it look like you posted on time), but now it's a week later and this is still sitting here unfinished.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Eddie,

    I've not read 'The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn' (I know, shame on me) but this book seems like a great choice for this particular prompt. I think due to my lack of prior knowledge for this book, this essay was a little harder to follow. I understood clearly that Pap is from the South, which could indicate the country and how that affected his views. But, I got a little confused about Huckleberry Finn. Does he live in the city where his views are not corrupted and filled with prejudice? Or does he live with Pap in the south? In the second body paragraph, I'm a little confused as to what value the host family has and if they live in the city or also the country. I do, however love your conclusion. It follows the prompt well, and if I were you, I would have taken your conclusion and changed it to make your introduction. The values that you wanted to talk about were clearly stated and it tied the prompt to the message of the book as a whole. I would say, if you had started off with an introduction very similar to your current conclusion, your essay would be much easier to write since your whole outline would already be written out for you. For this prompt, I think some students decided to go with the route of comparing the values from the country and the values from the cities. I'm not sure if cities were part of this particular book, but the idea is to emphasize the unique values that come specially from the effects of living in the country. But since I have no knowledge of this book, I could be completely wrong. Try to make it goal in your essay to have the readers be refreshed a little on what the book is about so they can connect the pieces more easily. I hope these tip will help you in these essays!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Eddie!

    I like this essay a lot! I remember reading this prompt and thinking that it sounded way too hard to write about, but you did a good job. Writing about Huck Finn was very smart, as it fits this prompt really well. I agree with Kathy that the conclusion seems like a better thesis paragraph than the one you have right now. Your current opening paragraph seems almost like a body paragraph, and does a little more summarizing than I think you would want in a thesis paragraph.

    I think you brought a lot of good evidence into your supporting paragraphs, and they really support your thesis. At first I wasn't totally sure where you were going with some of your evidence, but you brought everything together at the ends of your paragraphs, and especially in the concluding paragraph.

    Overall, I really like the direction you went with this essay. Nice work!

    ReplyDelete