In recent years, bicycling
has grown in popularity as a mode of transportation and a form of exercise. However, American drivers have struggled to safely and respectfully share
the roads with commuters and fitness enthusiasts who prefer bicycles, which
lack the degree of physical protection offered by larger vehicles. Injury and
death has frequently resulted from poor cooperation between these two rival
demographics, and those behind the wheel rarely face serious legal
consequences. In his opinion piece written for The New York Times, titled:
"Is It O.K. to Kill Cyclists?", Daniel Duane uses rhetorical
techniques like diction, imagery and detail to communicate the absurdity of this injustice
faced by cyclists.
Throughout the piece, Duane utilizes a blend of colloquial
and formal diction to establish his credibility while avoiding an air of
pretension, and to effectively express his position in a way that is accessible
to a wide range of readers. Words like "meagerness" and "negligence" color the piece with linguistic variety, while slang terms like
"hipster" and "fixie" give the piece cultural relevance
that a larger audience can identify with. More specifically, however, he uses
careful word choice to express his disbelief over a questionable pattern of
legal behavior. For example, Duane aptly states, "there is something undeniably screwy about a justice system that makes
it de facto legal to kill people." His use of the word "screwy" conveys a
sense of illogic, that not only makes this flaw in our justice system seem
wrong, but downright preposterous.
Duane also employs imagery as an intriguing opener for his appeal to our common sense. Recounting a particularly perilous bike ride, he writes "I watched an SUV driver hit another cyclist, and then I got my own front wheel caught in a streetcar track, sending me to the pavement." This image of misfortune draws readers in by providing an exaggerated example of the dangers faced by cyclists. Considering the controversial and emotionally-charged nature of this issue,
using language to illustrate tragic loss and the injustice that
inevitably follows is also a particularly effective tool for building a strong
position. For example, Duane creates a disturbing image by writing "If
your 13-year-old daughter bikes to school tomorrow inside a freshly painted
bike lane, and a driver runs a stop sign and kills her and then says to the
cop, 'Gee, I so totally did not mean to do that,' that will most likely be good
enough." By placing an image of innocence into the minds of his readers in
the form of a young girl, Duane opens us up to emotional response.
Subsequently, he is able to effectively elicit that sort of response by
subjecting that image to the sort of injustice that many cyclists who are
probably equally innocent--but less cute--unfortunately experience.
Additionally, Duane provides scads of detail to help strengthen his position. He includes an interesting quote from "bike law" attorney Ray Thomas that shines some light on the legal process surrounding a car/bike accident. According to Thomas "'jurors identify with drivers...they just think, well, I could make the same mistake. So they don't convict.'" This sort of relevant detail helps to validate Duane's argument by bringing up the jury's role in the issue. Because of the mandatory involvement of American citizens in jury duty, readers can relate to this information, and therefore become more actively engaged in his argument. On top of that, Duane included a real-life example of prejudice towards cyclists in their struggle for their share of the road. His anecdote about Sgt. Ernst and Ms. Le Moullac revealed a degree of indifference by the police toward the plight of wounded cyclists. Duane's incorporation of a specific instance in which proper consequences weren't appropriated to a guilty driver helps express the reality of a problem that touches everyone, whether you're behind the wheel or the handlebars.
Through his use of diction, imagery and detail, among other rhetorical techniques, Daniel Duane is able to spread awareness of a serious injustice, the repercussions of which are being felt by more and more as many Americans begin to adopt a new, two-wheeled lifestyle.
Additionally, Duane provides scads of detail to help strengthen his position. He includes an interesting quote from "bike law" attorney Ray Thomas that shines some light on the legal process surrounding a car/bike accident. According to Thomas "'jurors identify with drivers...they just think, well, I could make the same mistake. So they don't convict.'" This sort of relevant detail helps to validate Duane's argument by bringing up the jury's role in the issue. Because of the mandatory involvement of American citizens in jury duty, readers can relate to this information, and therefore become more actively engaged in his argument. On top of that, Duane included a real-life example of prejudice towards cyclists in their struggle for their share of the road. His anecdote about Sgt. Ernst and Ms. Le Moullac revealed a degree of indifference by the police toward the plight of wounded cyclists. Duane's incorporation of a specific instance in which proper consequences weren't appropriated to a guilty driver helps express the reality of a problem that touches everyone, whether you're behind the wheel or the handlebars.
Through his use of diction, imagery and detail, among other rhetorical techniques, Daniel Duane is able to spread awareness of a serious injustice, the repercussions of which are being felt by more and more as many Americans begin to adopt a new, two-wheeled lifestyle.
Eddie,
ReplyDeleteReally well done on your close reading! In general, I enjoy your clear writing style. It makes it easy for me to understand what you're saying with very, very little to no grammar, punctuation, or spelling errors. Your analysis of the diction, imagery, and detail used by Duane was exceptional, in my opinion. You provided examples of each with explanations to follow that made it clear why you would include them and how they added to the meaning of the article. I really can't say much else; I have no criticisms and no more appraisal than just: you did the job.
Hi Eddie, I really enjoyed reading your close reading post. I've struggled analyzing the language in the pieces of literature that we have read, your post had great examples in it that helped me notice how imagery can be used in a regular article. You do a good job of supporting your claims with quotes and the post was very organized which made it easy to follow. I thought the article seemed really interesting. I don’t think most people consider what cyclists have to deal with, and I agree that it is probably because most of us identify ourselves with the driver. I really like the title of this article, Is it Is It O.K. to Kill Cyclists?, it grabs a reader’s attention to the article. I think you could've used the title as evidence too if you needed more evidence, but you had plenty. Great close reading!
ReplyDeleteHey Eddie,
ReplyDeleteYou did a fantastic job on this close reading. Very clear and easy to follow. Especially when you had explained parts of the where the author used diction, imagery, and detail. I really liked that you had used many examples to support your claims and explained why they were included and what the effect of including them caused. You did a great job!