Ah, March: the threshold of spring. How terribly ironic for us Michiganders. In AP Lit., this chilly month has been stuffed with a variety of fascinating literary lessons, related in ways that--to be honest--I'm still figuring out. Following our wrap-up of RGAD, we took a brief hiatus from our constant dramatic analysis to explore a range of different literary works and multi-media presentations, beginning with some enlightening cultural essays written by Leslie Marmon Silko, the author of Ceremony. The essays contained valuable information regarding--among other things--the importance of the oral tradition to the Laguna Pueblo people, and went into considerable detail to depict some of the most culturally significant stories passed down through their generations. Reading Silko's work reminded me of some of the material we read in American Literature on American Indian tribes and the mythology around which their culture is based. Silko's description of a story in which a ka'tsina spirit known as "The Gambler" stole the rain-giving clouds as an ante for a bet particularly resonated with me, as I recognized the mischievous trickster spirit as a possible common archetype associated with tribal mythology. The character reminded me in particular of Loki--the infamous trickster god of Norse origins who happened to be prominently featured in the recently released Avengers movie. That connection got me thinking about shared symbols, which segued beautifully into the critical lenses powerpoint we viewed later in the week.
The powerpoint and our subsequent in-class discussion was useful in refreshing my memory regarding the various methods by which to analyze literature, as well as introduce me to a few I had never really been familiar with (Literary Darwinism, anybody?). I felt most comfortable with Marxism and Historical Criticism, two tried-and-true lenses that Ms. Huntley had us using quite frequently last year in Brit. Lit. As a class, however, we struggled right away as we tried to analyze The American Dream from a Feminist viewpoint. It seemed as though our understanding of that particular critical method was pretty vague, and it took extensive guidance from Ms. Holmes before we were able to get anywhere. I had used a Feminist lens numerous times in my analysis of Jane Eyre last year, and it seems I didn't quite have the hold on it that I thought I did. Oh well, you live and you learn. Time to go burn all those critical analysis papers on Brönte.
Anyway, I found the lesson on Northrop Frye's "Mythoi" to be hands-down the most intriguing of the month. His categorized, methodical approach to literature especially appealed to me as someone who likes to stay organized. It was also quite satisfying to recall Foster's How to Read Literature Like a Professor And recognize a lot of Frye's ideas in those chapters. Aside from that though, I found myself disagreeing with a number of my classmates when classifying works we've read under one of Frye's four seasonally-themed labels. It seems as though his system doesn't always account for the various nuances in works of modern literature like The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, for example. My understanding of his work is by no means complete, though, and I'd like to spend more time with it in the near future.
Regarding the next piece on our analytic docket, I've found Ceremony to be a powerful, gut-wrenching read. It's required a complete investment of focus due to the frequent chronological jumps, but so far it has been very rewarding. I can't wait to hear everyone's ideas and opinions. I unfortunately missed our first day of discussion on Monday due to a nasty illness. However, I heard we didn't cover too much in sixth hour, save constructing a family tree in order to get the characters straight, so I'm not very worried about catching up. That about covers our work in AP Lit. these past couple of weeks--here's to further literary enlightenment and better weather!
I hope you don't really feel like you have to burn all of your Brönte analyses! =) You're keeping in mind our discussions about the acquisition of language skills being recursive, right? So I tell you things that are different from what earlier teachers told you not because there's a conflict in the information (usually) but because you're ready for a more sophisticated level of understanding--of feminism, of the archetypes, of whatever. Don't focus on what you didn't know last year and feel embarrassment--celebrate what you know today! =)
ReplyDeleteHi Eddie! Great job on this post, it's very thorough and relatable. The Gambler story is actually my favorite in Ceremony, so much so that I actually went back to reread it, just because I could (I made sure that it got annotated in my 50 pages). Our class, unlike yours, didn't have trouble with the feminist theory, perhaps due to the 7:1 ratio of girls to boys in second hour. We talked mostly about feminism (to my delight) and every time the subject was changed it somehow got shoved back to the lens. I also loved the Northrop Frye theory (mainly just because of his name though). It's strange to me that our definitions of romance and tragedy often differ so much from their actual literary definitions. It makes me wonder how they got so disconnected. Nice work!
ReplyDeleteFirst off, Madison, the Northrop Frye definitions of Tragedy and Romance are specific to Frye's Mythoi, and do not extend to the whole of literary analysis, so don't worry about the disconnect there.
ReplyDeleteEddie,
Nice post and all that. Great connections and everything--by this late you've got it down pat. So moving on. Let's talk Frye. I totally agree with you that Frye's mythoi was the most interesting lesson in this segment. We all heard the One Story thing from Foster, but it didn't really make sense to me until we talked about the mythoi. I just always felt like there was something missing, but Frye filled all that in for me. The most interesting part for me, though, was the discussion of how each mythos fits into the development of a culture, and how each is necessary and naturally arises as a culture develops--how we need our heroes to prove the validity of our culture as the first most important thing, and whatnot. So incredibly interesting and enlightening to me. What did you think?
Eddie,
ReplyDeleteHa-ha, yeah, I also had a much different idea of the feminist lens from my dealings with it in my American Literature class last year, but I guess that part of that is just because we hadn’t gone as deep as I thought we had when learning about it. Knowing that there’s much more to it though is cool, as it only adds a layer of understanding on our part.
I’d also have to agree that Frye’s Mythoi is one of the neatest subjects we’ve touched upon this semester. Working with it again in the future would be fun, but with the AP exam so close I don’t think we’ll get the chance to. Oh, and I really enjoy some of the connections you drew such as finding a way to relate “The Gambler” from Laguna tradition to Loki, not only from Norse mythology, but then also the Avengers movie.
P.S. ~ We weren’t really the ones who made that family tree you saw on the board. First hour made that, and we spent the entire hour except for the last two minutes wrapping up a poetry analysis or whatever it was we were doing that day. :P