Sunday, March 9, 2014

Open Prompt Response #2

(2004 Prompt, Question #3: Critic Roland Barthes has said, "Literature is the question minus the answer." Choose a novel, or play, and, considering Barthes' observation, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the author's treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary.)

In Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead, Tom Stoppard re-introduces readers to a pair of bumbling minor characters from Shakespeare's Hamlet, as they wander without purpose or direction through someone else's play. Through their own constant inaction, as well as a number of mysterious clues provided by a curious troupe of tragedians, Stoppard establishes that within their literary realm, the ultimate fate of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern is contained in the very script by which they operate. In this way, Stoppard asserts that characters--existing only in a work of art--are completely without free will or a sense of control. However, by making careful distinctions between his characters and the audience watching them (and consequently art and reality) throughout the play, Stoppard both raises answers the question: "Do we, real humans, have a sense of control, or is it merely an illusion that we endorse?"
      From the moment the titular duo arrives on stage, it is already clear that they are defined by their idleness. We first find them betting on the flip of a coin--for nearly the 100th time. Arbitrary games like these occupy their time whenever they aren't fulfilling their obligations as characters in Hamlet, suggesting that any sense of purpose they had during their "scenes" vanishes once they are on their own outside of the action. Another character, the enigmatic Player, also gives us reason to believe that the pair's fate is beyond their control. In fact, he even goes so far as to respond to one of Rosencrantz's mindless queries with: "Decides? It is written." Another equally conspicuous example of the Player's peculiar sense of awareness is his troupe's foretelling performance that depicts Ros and Guil's deaths right in front of their own puzzled faces. Ros and Guil's inability to put two and two together says something about their characters in and of itself. After all, they couldn't possibly exercise free will if they aren't even aware of their situation.
      While concurrently establishing the doomed nature of the play's protagonists, Stoppard also emphasizes a distinct separation between the characters onstage and the audience off. Often times, Ros and Guil themselves acknowledge the different features of the stage on which they are confined, paying particular attention to the footlights, as if they represent some sort of final barrier that keeps them from escaping the horrifying, cyclical eternity they are forced to endure as characters. In the third act, the two express particular longing to escape from their play. In fact, Ros even considers "jumping ship" and joining the audience in reality at one point, only to be discouraged by Guil's brief yet tragic intuition that "they" (the authors) are probably expecting it.
      Ultimately the sad plight of the titular characters, and the obvious evidence that they are confined to the literary work in which their fate is written begs us readers to reflect inwards to some degree. Stoppard asks us: Do you have control? Can you exercise free will? And, in much the same way that he asked that question, he answers it. Though he meant for his characters to reflect certain aspects of human nature which he undoubtedly finds somewhat weak or pathetic--such as indecision or indifference--he clearly intended for us to recognize that his characters are trapped within their play, while we exist in an entirely different realm that is as chaotic and complex as theirs, but remains magnificently unscripted. By way of this difference, he breaks off the possibility of relation to these characters, and reminds us that we do possess free will, and that we should employ it in a way that allows us to find purpose and a sense of identity, two things that his bewildered protagonists severely lack, and can never obtain.


2 comments:

  1. Eddie,

    Nice job, overall. A solid, and very well-written essay. Your voice makes it a very interesting read, and the essay is very coherent, so I just have a few comments. First of all, I thought you had it structured well, but then you didn't quite do it the way I expected, as you rolled what ought to have been your third body paragraph into your conclusion, which made it over-long, and a little out of place. The points still made sense, but I would have put your discussion of the question itself in its own body paragraph and then just brought it all back together in the conclusion. Otherwise, your essay is clean, clear, and logical. The only other comment I have is a disagreement with the content: did you really see the cycle as horrifying? I read the tone of it significantly differently, judging from that and other diction choices in your essay.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Eddie,

    The diction you use is fantastic and makes the essay so enjoyable to read. There’s not much I have to suggest here because you’ve done so well already. For a while it did seem a bit unclarified as to how Stoppard answers the question posed in your thesis statement, but the conclusion paragraph cleans up what you were digging out in the second body paragraph. One word is missing from your thesis in-between the words “raises” and “answers,” which is only a problem because depending on which word is supposed to fit on there the whole meaning of your thesis could be flipped around, but the conclusion solidifies that you meant to continue talking in the positive. You do a very good job at avoiding plot summary as well. Nice work, I think this would have received a high score had it been the actual essay you’d written for the AP exam. :D

    ReplyDelete