Wednesday, January 8, 2014

Response to Course Material: December

      Our time in the AP Lit. classroom this past month could be very appropriately described as an in-depth exploration of Shakespeare's finest tragedy on the page, stage, and screen. Or, somewhat less gracefully: a whole lotta Hamlet. Either way, intriguing discussion was generated, and exciting revelations were had by all. After finishing the play in late November and enjoying some preliminary discussion, Holmes had us share our ideas through an online forum. We responded to a few different Hamlet-related pieces, the most notable being a NPR feature covering a production of Hamlet being staged by convicts in a penitentiary. My biggest take-away, as was undoubtedly intended, was a discovery of the universal nature of the play and its central themes. Listening to a group of men, who by no means match the noble stature of their characters, portray their roles with such raw emotion was eye-opening for me as a reader and as an actor. Whenever I rehearse or perform, I try to remind myself that drama is not simply imitating someone else, but sharing their emotions. This article helped me realize that Hamlet's themes are so deeply ingrained in human condition, anyone can relate to the struggles depicted within its pages. Beneath the technicalities of the plot and setting, its that sense of common anguish that makes Hamlet such a distinguished member of the literary canon.
     Following our forum discussion, we spent class-time watching the first of many Hamlet film adaptations, this one directed and starred in by the great--and recently knighted--Sir Kenneth Branagh. I found it very interesting to see the artistic conventions of film applied to a piece whose history is so deeply rooted in the theatre. This particular adaptation adopted many popular aspects of contemporary film culture, including a sort of action movie vibe that I thought contributed to its sweeping, epic mood. Ultimately, though, I felt that this approach did something to distract the viewer from the more personal, intimate conflicts of the play. For example, Hamlet's public execution of his uncle, King Claudius, would've been more fitting as the climax of a Steven Spielberg film, considering the grandiose nature of his chandelier-swinging, rapier-hurling display of violence at the end. He went a little Indiana Jones on us there. In considerable contrast, our next viewing was of a recent BBC production with a more modern-day take on the play, with Scottish actor and former Time Lord David Tenant in the title role. Where Branagh's version was extravagant, this was understated. Simple costumes and more modest set pieces characterized this production, and--along with the natural, more contemporary performances by Tenant and co.--helped to achieve a sense of realism without diminishing the power of the text. The other three film versions we explored were those starring Derek Jacobi, Ethan Hawke, and Laurence Olivier. As we continued to absorb all these different Hamlets, I began to notice subtleties between the performances that revealed a new a way of interpreting the text. For example, Olivier's delivery of the famous "To Be Or Not To Be" soliloquy, along with his position and body language gave the speech an intense sensuality which spurred some quality discussion in class. We also watched an episode of the PBS series "Shakespeare Uncovered" which focused heavily on the process of actually playing Hamlet. The episode was hosted by none other than David Tenant, who reflected on his recent portrayal of Hamlet as a member of The Royal Shakespeare Company. I particularly appreciated actor Jude Law's insight during an interview with Tenant. He spoke with great enthusiasm about his struggle to step into a role with such history and complexity behind it. He went on to say that the complexity of the character is what gave him artistic freedom in the end, which I think is an interesting concept, and a big part of why Hamlet is so iconic. Readers can interpret the character of Hamlet in so many ways--and receive satisfaction from those interpretations--because of how multi-faceted he is. That insight has helped me to be less objective in my analysis, and ties into to one of the articles we read for our forum assignment. An anthropologist's struggle to find common ground with an African Tribal leader on the themes of Hamlet illustrates this complexity in a cross-cultural context.
      As we wrap up our discussion and analysis of Hamlet in class, I'm excited to work on a theme statement that can more clearly represent our collective musings on the text. It's been an enlightening experience to say the least, and I'm sure it's not the last I'll see of the Danish prince.
   

3 comments:

  1. Eddie,
    You covered everything we've done in class I'm pretty sure. You even included the Shakespeare uncovered film which I forgot (thanks for reminding me!). I liked your insight into how relatable Hamlet is for everyone as shown through the NPR story, which I also found fascinating. Especially considering that many of the convicts hadn't finished high school and were performing one of the most difficult to understand plays. But after all I shouldn't have found it so surprising they could relate to Hamlet’s situation because they too are trapped in a prison like Hamlet is in Elsinore. I liked your comparison of the Branagh version to Indiana Jones and see the similarities in action. One thing you might want to add is another outside of class connection because the only one you have is the Indiana Jones reference. Perhaps how something in class discussion reminded you of something else.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Eddie,
    This post was very thorough, and you covered much more than I did in my response to course material. I was really interested in the connections you made with the play and NPR story as an actor, and I also find the universal message of Shakespeare's plays (and I guess all of literature too...) to be very intriguing. Judging from your early description, I assume that Hamlet is your favorite Shakespearean work, so do you think that Hamlet really spoke with the prisoners or was it Shakespeare? In other words, do you think that the prisoners would be able to create the same link to another play like Titus Andronicus or Julius Caesar? I like how, throughout your description of the films, you sort of picked out the details that really spoke to you, but I would caution that it was starting to seem a bit too much like the summary Holmes warns us about. You were really responding to the material, but I think that you might want to add some more connections to your learning and experience outside of class. In all, this is a very thorough and detailed post, which clearly illustrates how much you enjoy the material. Add a few more synthesized connections, and you will be golden!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Eddie,
    Great job! Your post covered all the important topics that we have covered in December. I liked your own connection to the NPR story. I also the NPR quite interesting considering these were convicts who were trying to act out Hamlet. Just the entire story was filled with real emotions and motives. Your opinions about the movies was very amusing especially your connection with Indiana Jones. The only thing I would add to this post would be something about the "Tragic Balance in Hamlet" and "Hamlet Source Material"
    Other than that, keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete