Sunday, December 8, 2013

Critical Response Essay: Why Mandela Was Unique

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/11/opinion/friedman-why-mandela-was-unique.html?ref=opinion

      The recent passing of Nelson Mandela has resulted in an outpour of reverence and recollection from around the globe. In the wake of his death on December 5, 2013, people everywhere took time to think about the achievements of a truly magnificent individual who used his time on earth to make it a better place. In an op-ed piece for the New York Times, Thomas L. Friedman asks: "why was Mandela unique?" He uses rhetorical techniques like diction, syntax and detail to answer this question and explain how one mankind's greatest leaders earned the love and admiration of the entire world.
      For the most part, Friedman uses colloquial diction in this piece. Seeing as the main purpose of the article was to pay tribute to a great man whose influence spreads far and wide, he avoids using elevated language that may alienate some readers and detract from his overall message. That's not to say Friedman dumbs down his writing style. His diction is careful and expressive, using words like "humility" and "restraint" to identify some of Mandela's key virtues, and describing the South African President's ability "to elevate others". Those words embody Mandela as a human being and a symbol, and help to remind us of his incredible distinction in leadership. Friedman also uses diction to effectively capture the world's reaction to Mandela's passing in his introduction, which reads: "The global outpouring of respect for Nelson Mandela suggests that we're not just saying goodbye to the man at his death, but that were losing a certain kind of leader, unique on the world stage today, and we are mourning that just as much."His choice of the words "outpouring" and "mourning" help to communicate the magnitude of the world's loss.
      Syntactical elements are also instrumental in Friedman's attempt to examine a true global icon. For example, parallel structure creates a rhythm that adds a certain gravitas to his line: "It is easy to lead by telling your own base what it wants to hear. It is easy to lead by giving things away. It is easy to lead when things are going well". This parallelism builds momentum and makes it even more affecting when Friedman discusses Mandela's rejection of what was easy in order to do what was right.  In addition to that, syntax also plays a big part in expressing the terrible obstacles that Mandela struggled against in his lifetime. Friedman describes the the "bitter, entrenched, white rule" that black South Africans faced during Apartheid. The use of asyndeton here places a special emphasis on the word "entrenched", which further express the hopeless situation of the South African people during that time.
      Through the inclusion of relevant detail, Friedman heightens the emotional and intellectual affect of his piece by providing a bit of context. For example, he includes a brief summary of the film Invictus in order to establish a historical background for his discussion of Mandela's achievements during his first year as President. This facilitates a better understanding of the man and his choices in the face of a nation still divided by deeply-rooted prejudice and a desire for retribution. Friedman also consulted with political consultant Dov Siedman for the article, who provided some valuable detail in the form of a comparison between Mandela's political style and that of today's politicians. Siedman comments that "so much of American politics today is about how I narrowcast to this poll-tested demographic in this ZIP code to get just enough voters to shift to my side to give me 50.1 percent...Mandela's leadership genius was his ability to enlist a critical mass of South Africans to elevate, to go to a new place, not just shift a few votes at the margin". Through this apt juxtaposition, Mandela's unique value to the global community is revealed
      Through his use of rhetorical techniques like diction, syntax and detail, Friedman was able to pen a fitting tribute to a leader who's passing reminds us that the work he did for humanity lives on forever.

2 comments:

  1. Eddie,
    Great article choice. Your diction analysis had great examples that backed up your claim of colloquial diction. You should make it slightly more clear about how the colloquial diction adds to Friedman’s meaning of the article. You lead the reader to it but I think you should make it crystal clear at least once what the meaning of the piece is. Also, the words you chose to quote for diction you should say how everyone understands them and can relate to them. Your syntax analysis was perfect and prime example of vocab words like asyndeton. To further your analysis of details you could bring up how the focus on those details and not others add to the meaning that Mandela was adored globally. You did a great job in that paragraph of connecting the details in Friedman’s article to his meaning.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Eddie,
    Your analysis of this article really demonstrated a strong grasp of DIDLS, and I really enjoyed reading your views on the author's rhetorical technique. As I read through your argument, I noticed that you drew from a variety of good evidence, which helps get your point across. Your analysis of syntax was really well-crafted, and I especially liked how you went into how the structure "builds momentum." I often find myself just leaving it at "oh it builds emotion or tension," but you actually described this with a specific trend ("parallelism"). Another thing I liked was how you went through your diction analysis, describing each of the trends as a choice the author made. I feel like you might have elaborated a bit more in certain areas, such as in your description of the juxtaposed details, but otherwise, you really hit the mark.

    ReplyDelete