Sunday, November 17, 2013

Open Prompt Critique (#3)

(2006 Prompt, Question #3: "Country Setting as a Source of Values")

Critique #1: This student crafts a complete essay that responds directly to the prompt in an insightful way. She begins well, acknowledging a counter-argument in her thesis statement, and then effectively presenting her own position in contrast. This technique provides a certain clarity to the reader that helps them identify exactly the direction in which the rest of the piece will go. She then carefully separates her claims about setting in Jane Austen's Persuasion into body paragraphs that retain their focus throughout. Her language isn't confusing or contradictory, either, give or take a few grammatical/spelling slip-ups. In addition, she's careful to conclude each body paragraph with a warranting sentence that ties her evidence back to her thesis. Looking at the grader's response, I was legitimately surprised at the students grade of an 8. Personally, I couldn't find any issues significant enough to justify the loss of a point. Perhaps the student could have been more direct in her conclusion. I suppose her focus waivers slightly in the final paragraph, and technically speaking, a more clear restatement of her thesis may have gotten her that last point. Personally, though, I liked the flow of her conclusion, and I think it served it's function of wrapping up her essay and re-hashing her argument. I'd give this student a 9.

Critique #2: This student is only partially effective in answering the entire prompt, and fails to present valuable evidence in a way that highlights it's connection to his thesis statement. In his introductory paragraph, the student establishes the country setting in The Importance of Being Ernest as one of "tranquility", but fails to provide evidence for this claim in any of his body paragraphs. Instead, he mainly focuses on the function of two settings (rural vs. urban) in the comedic process. His first body paragraph is all summary, and doesn't refer to the prompt or the thesis at all, while his only other body paragraph addresses a portion of his thesis, but fails to explain how the country setting serves as a source of values, as delineated in the prompt. The essay received an official score of 6, which I think could've have been raised if the student crafted a more complete thesis statement that made claims according to the prompt, instead of getting distracted by the role of the setting in creating comedy. I think This would have helped to keep the student on track to construct a tighter essay. As it is though, I'd give this student no more than a 5.

Critique #3: This student attempts answers the prompt with a unique position, but she provides little relevant evidence and her phrasing is nearly incomprehensible, squandering any potential her essay may have had. Firstly, the student fails to clearly identify a thesis statement that establishes her claims, and the introductory paragraph in general is very vague. The rest of the essay is devoted to explaining how Faulkner used the setting of the south, as morally "backwards" as it is, as a plot device to justify the actions of the bizarre actions of the characters in As I Lay Dying. While this claim, were it clearly identified, would be an effective answer to the prompt, the textual evidence included by the student fails to reinforce the rural setting as a source of values. Instead, she focuses on the strange behavior of the characters and provides inadequate warrants back to her essentially non-existent thesis statement. This student received a score of 4, which honestly seems a little generous. I think the student could have benefited from spending more time on the organization of her thoughts, as well as her construction of warrants. The root of the problem, however, seems to be her lack of a real thesis statement, which generally serves as the cornerstone of a writer's argument. I'd give this student a 3.

3 comments:

  1. Eddie,
    I enjoy your honesty in disagreeing with the official grade of the first student's essay. Not many students do this; they usually just agree with whatever the official grader gave. The first sentence of each of your criticisms clearly states what, in general, the student did right or wrong in reference to answering the prompt. You continued to give sufficient explanations of all rights and wrongs in each student's writing. I also liked how you gave tips for the second student in how to raise his grade from a 6, something I've only seen from one other AP student but I should see from everyone else (including myself), since it gives a more complete criticism. In all, I find your writing to be completely adequate and more--you fully read and understand these student essays and it is shown through your writing clearly.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Eddie,
    You and I picked the same open prompts to analyse and respond to. I also thought that the first essay should have received a 9 instead of an 8. I don’t think there is that much distinction between the two scores; what separates could possibly be something trivial. I hadn’t really noticed any issues with the conclusion after you pointed them out though I agree. I noticed that there were a few technical error and then the only other issue I noticed was that the student didn’t follow the order their thesis was in. That might of hurt their score a bit too. I like that you wrote what score you would give them if you were the grader. You do a good job of responding to the second and third essays too. I think using more quotes from the essays would strengthen your analysis more. Great job with the open prompts.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Eddie,
    You did great job on this open prompt, one thing I really liked about this is that you said that the student should have gotten a 9 instead of an 8. Having your own opinion on what the essays are really good. I also liked that you gave some explanations on how the student could have improved his score, which I found myself doing a lot too because I think it really helps other people to see these and maybe have second look on their essays. You did a great job of responding to each of the essays and pointing out the rights and wrongs. Nice work!

    ReplyDelete