Sunday, September 15, 2013

Critical Response Essay: In the End, New Yorkers Reject Bad Boy Candidates

http://ideas.time.com/2013/09/11/in-the-end-new-yorkers-reject-bad-boy-candidates/

Scandalous politicians have been on a roll in the city of New York this past year, and a flood of opinion pieces have been published in response. In this article, Time contributor Errol Louis uses rhetorical elements like diction, language, and details to comment on the absurdity of his hometown's political scene, while concurrently providing readers with an explanation.
      Firstly, Louis's use of colloquial diction makes his article accessible to the average reader, which is imperative in order for it's message to hit home. After all, the piece is ultimately about the diversity of our country's greatest city, and the tolerance that is required of its residents. A universal message like that demands a voice that the people of all walks of life can understand and relate to. He even uses the occasional slang term like "bad boy" to subtly make fun of the politicians under scrutiny, a bit of humor that can draw reader's attention and help them to connect with the meaning of the piece. Even so, he uses diction intelligently enough to communicate his credibility, particularly when providing readers with data from the polls, supporting his claims about New Yorkers' political response.
      Secondly, Louis uses language that highlights the important elements of his message. Words like "paradox"--as used in the first sentence--effectively express his claim that tolerance and acceptance are fundamentally different concepts, an idea that contrasts with our general knowledge of the words, but which further reading reveals to be true. In addition, his frequent use of the term "diversity" challenges our typical understanding of the word. Personally, I generally apply it to ethnic or racial differences, but here Louis uses it to describe the cultural and behavioral differences between people, a usage that is perhaps more appropriate in a country that ought to focus less on the geographical origins of its residents, and more on how they can contribute to their communities. Through language, we notice somewhat of a subtext in the article.
     Thirdly, Louis includes plenty of detail in order to emphasize the difference between people--and between politicians--that makes a level of tolerance so important to everyday life, particularly in a diverse metropolis like NYC. For example, Louis notes how "punk rockers live next door to opera fans" and he even recognizes how LGBTQ societies can occasionally find some common ground with religious groups. By highlighting the ways in which our behaviors differ, he more vividly illustrates his point to his readers.
     Through rhetoric, Errol Louis not only explained why New Yorkers have a tendency to entertain the brash behavior of some of its political icons, but he implied that such tolerance might not be a bad thing after all. In fact, Louis implies, it's probably a direction the entire country should head in--as long as we don't forget how to "quietly reject" the "bad boys"in the end.

3 comments:

  1. I absolutely agree with your first point; Louis' use of colloquial language makes the piece seem casual, but not unpleasantly so. And by using that technique, he makes it easier for more people to read, which is good as his message is something people (especially New Yorkers) should consider. And while I agree with your observation of his usage of the word "paradox", I don't really agree with the author's idea. I don't think we "go out of our way" to accept seemingly suspicious people. I think his article totally contradicts his opening statement. I'm also a bit unsure of the strength of your third paragraph. I don't understand how his examples of diversity make for a stronger essay. Overall, I think your essay analyzing his op-ed piece was pretty strong and made a lot of good points, but I also think that next time an essay that took a heavier stance on an issue would make your life much easier.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Eddie,

    Just as a quick note, you briefly switched to past tense in the beginning of your conclusion paragraph so you may want to change that to present since your post is discussing a form of literature. Honestly, I think that your blog post is solid. Louis’s idea that while the people may tolerate something on the outside, they may not necessarily feel good about it on the inside is finely articulated here. You may want to spell out acronyms like LGBTQ that are not located in the article though since not everyone is probably familiar with it. I think you can probably get away with certain ones like NYC, but do you think LGBTQ can be considered common knowledge (90%)? The one other thing I would suggest is to try to fit more evidence in. So instead of using one quote per paragraph, try to back it up even more with a second one. Adding more meat to the argument always help, just pay attention to make sure you are not letting the quality of your warrants drop. In my opinion, one good piece of evidence complete with a holistic warrant is better than two choppy ones any day.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Eddie,

    Nice job on the response, and an interesting article, but I have a few things I want to point out. First of all, I don't think the summary of the article you give in the first paragraph of your post accurately encompasses the purpose of the essay. It doesn't seem to me that the author's purpose is to "[point] out the absurdity of his hometown's political scene," but really more to defend NYC's political scene as not really being as absurd as it seems. It actually seems to me, as a whole, that he is trying to using the recent political news in NYC as an example to show that NYC's liberalism is really only skin-deep, and that New Yorkers tolerate, rather than accept. On that note, in your third paragraph you talk about how those two ideas are usually used almost synonymously, but I disagree. For me they have very different connotations, with "tolerance" almost having a begrudging aspect to it, whereas "acceptance" feels more complete and welcoming, and I think the author does a great job of showing how that difference can manifest itself. To otherwise address that paragraph, I don't think it was really language, as you labeled it. The claims and evidence you presented there would have fit better under diction, rather than figurative language, since they dealt with the use of specific words like "paradox" and "diversity." I also agree with Blake that you did a good job formulating your arguments, but could use more evidence to support your position.

    ReplyDelete